mpv icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
mpv copied to clipboard

[meta] Can you open the Github 'discussions' on this repo?

Open 07416 opened this issue 3 years ago • 4 comments

an example repo with the discussions open: https://github.com/yt-dlp/yt-dlp/discussions

While the 'question' tag/category is enabled, the issues is not an optimal fit for subjective topics, I feel. May also reduce the maintainer burden by lowering the amount of created issues.

07416 avatar Jun 05 '22 12:06 07416

I agree this would be a good idea, I don't like the question template's existence as some people use it to report actual issues and then not include log files.

We'd need people we can trust who will moderate the discussions pages though, things will probably get out of hand quickly when someone asks what "the best user shader" is or whatever.

CounterPillow avatar Jun 05 '22 15:06 CounterPillow

Another issue is people whose questions are answered don't say so, and then the issues stay open, cluttering open issues.

Traneptora avatar Jun 05 '22 15:06 Traneptora

We'd need people we can trust who will moderate the discussions pages though, things will probably get out of hand quickly when someone asks what "the best user shader" is or whatever.

That's quite important. And make a rule to prevent large amounts of simple questions such as "how to set volume/speed/sat". A bad example is reddit/mpv, which is full of those kinda terrible threads.

hooke007 avatar Jun 05 '22 16:06 hooke007

It's enabled in the staxrip and mpv.net repo, has a like issues a Pin feature, what if necessary can be used to pin rules or guidelines.

stax76 avatar Jun 12 '22 18:06 stax76

We'd need people we can trust who will moderate the discussions pages though, things will probably get out of hand quickly when someone asks what "the best user shader" is or whatever.

That's quite important. And make a rule to prevent large amounts of simple questions such as "how to set volume/speed/sat". A bad example is reddit/mpv, which is full of those kinda terrible threads.

A comprehensive, pinned easy-to-read FAQ alone should prevent most of the such questions from being asked.

I'd also prohibit sharing entire config files and instructing people to use one as it is.

ghost avatar Oct 14 '23 06:10 ghost

https://github.com/mpv-player/mpv/discussions have fun!

kasper93 avatar Apr 16 '24 17:04 kasper93