OpenDesign icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
OpenDesign copied to clipboard

Contribution Guidelines needed to guide new contributors through copyright issues

Open asdofindia opened this issue 6 years ago • 11 comments

Goal:

Contribution guidelines for open design

Info:

It will be used for guiding new contributors to the open design community to avoid copyright issues in the designs that they create.

Style Information:

It will look like http://www.howdesign.com/featured/graphic-design-copyright-laws-inspiration-vs-infringement/ https://opensource.guide/legal/ and https://www.business.com/articles/the-copyright-question-the-difference-between-inspiration-and-infringement/ put together

Deadline:

Whenever

Tag:

[Volunteer needed]

asdofindia avatar Nov 06 '18 01:11 asdofindia

Hello!

Do you have the content already?

pransh15 avatar Nov 19 '18 10:11 pransh15

@pransh15 erm, content is there all over the web. (Like the links I put in the issue).

asdofindia avatar Nov 24 '18 06:11 asdofindia

Is this related to design or just updating the repo with content for Contribution guidelines?

kindavishal avatar Apr 20 '19 13:04 kindavishal

It is a meta issue, not a request for a design

asdofindia avatar Apr 20 '19 14:04 asdofindia

I understand, this is indeed important. We can work on writing a template for this. Tagging @elioqoshi @yofiesetiawan @barrosgeraldo @pransh15 for suggestions on this.

kindavishal avatar Apr 22 '19 05:04 kindavishal

Please tag more people who you think can be helpful in this.

kindavishal avatar Apr 22 '19 05:04 kindavishal

We're basically talking about adding a CONTRIBUTING.md file here, aren't we? (Some recommendations by GitHub at the end of the article).

Ryuno-Ki avatar Apr 24 '19 20:04 Ryuno-Ki

Sorry for missing this.

The idea was in the beginning that all content here would be licensed under CC-BY 4.0 for external usage and no need for attribution for usage within Mozilla projects.

My suggestion for attribution would be to refer to it as "Mozilla Open Design" instead of individual contributors and list the list of core contributors in the ReadMe and/or Contributors.md

Some house keeping is long overdue definitely. I will try to help with that once I get a chance.

elioqoshi avatar May 15 '19 09:05 elioqoshi

Elio, I will add some context. There is very little awareness about the concept of copyright among the people of India. This is certainly applicable to "graphic designers" as well. Many a times, designs created are blatantly violating others' rights. I have seen this happening within Mozilla community. The need for guidelines is here. To avoid content of questionable ownership being contributed to this repository

asdofindia avatar May 15 '19 09:05 asdofindia

@asdofindia Right, I didn't touch on this point. Unfortunately we cannot check ourselves if something is violating any copyright but we can definitely create guidelines to ensure people are aware at least. Generally speaking, since we are offering designs here for Mozilla projects without attribution, we would only be able to use CC0 Public Domain resources for the created artwork here. Anything which is not Public Domain or where the contributor holds the rights of, is not compatible with the licensing of this repo.

elioqoshi avatar May 15 '19 09:05 elioqoshi

Adding my 2 cents here, I think if we describe the guidelines as mentioned in Design Mozilla since most of the work on this repo mainly revolves around them, would be a good point.

kindavishal avatar Jul 09 '19 14:07 kindavishal