Player icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
Player copied to clipboard

Disable picture in picture (PIP) on Android TV

Open brentonv opened this issue 3 years ago • 6 comments

I've tried all different display modes on different devices and it seems PIP is displaying as an option on Android TV and there is no way to disable it. Is this normal or are the player options not displaying correctly?

The reason I ask is that the button is easily pressed in error and there is no way to escape PIP on Android TV without force closing the player

If this is how it is intended, can you please consider including an option to disable PIP🙏

Thanks

brentonv avatar Nov 13 '21 06:11 brentonv

The PiP functionality is a standard Android OS feature. Closing/dismissing may be altered by the device manufacturer. On my devices and the emulator, I can switch and dismiss the PiP from controls on the home screen. The PiP should just work the same as in other apps offering PiP functionality.

moneytoo avatar Nov 13 '21 07:11 moneytoo

Thanks for the reply @moneytoo. As you can see here I don't get any such controls on the home screen of the very common Android TV device NVIDIA Shield Pro 2019. The only option is to force close the app from the app settings menu

brentonv avatar Nov 13 '21 13:11 brentonv

Switching the the app should also dismiss PiP. It should really be no different than with other apps (you may try for example PiP in Youtube/SmartTubeNext).

moneytoo avatar Nov 13 '21 20:11 moneytoo

Switching the the app should also dismiss PiP

I already showed the app switcher. There is nothing there..

brentonv avatar Nov 14 '21 01:11 brentonv

Stock Android TV doesn't include app/task switcher so normally would need to select it from home screen/launcher. What happens when you do that?

moneytoo avatar Nov 14 '21 06:11 moneytoo

Stock Android TV doesn't include app/task switcher

NVIDIA Shield Pro 2019 definitely includes an app switcher but Just Player does not show. There is nothing there when displaying PIP

you may try for example PiP in Youtube/SmartTubeNext

This is SmartTubeNext in the app switcher

select it from home screen/launcher. What happens when you do that?

Navigating to find the app launcher from app drawer/app settings will restore the player again but this is clumsy. A setting to disable PIP would be ideal

Please consider adding this🙏

brentonv avatar Nov 14 '21 07:11 brentonv

Unfortunately I'm unable to reproduce this issue and therefore to do anything with it.

moneytoo avatar Nov 28 '22 16:11 moneytoo