MSTMap does not have `observe` method, but IMSTMap does

[n9]

Bug report

• [x] I've checked documentation and searched for existing issues and discussions
• [x] I've made sure my project is based on the latest MST version
• [x] Fork this code sandbox or another minimal reproduction.

Sandbox link or minimal reproduction code

https://codesandbox.io/p/devbox/nameless-shadow-987q7v?workspaceId=ws_V6MwkdyBVdYpA4KMGgF9f5

import { types } from "mobx-state-tree";

const Tweet = types
  .model("Tweet", {
    body: types.string,
    read: false, // automatically inferred as type "boolean" with default "false"
  })
  .actions((tweet) => ({
    toggle() {
      tweet.read = !tweet.read;
    },
  }));

const TwitterStore = types.model("TwitterStore", {
  tweets: types.map(Tweet),
});

// create an instance from a snapshot
const twitterStore = TwitterStore.create();

twitterStore.tweets.observe((c) => {}); // 🐞 twitterStore.tweets.observe is not a function

Describe the expected behavior

It will not crash.

Describe the observed behavior

It crashes with twitterStore.tweets.observe is not a function.

Thoughts

I assume the cause is that the ObservableMap no longer have the observe method.

PS: Maybe MSTMap should also implement IMSTMap?

[n9]

As a workaround, I tried MobX's observe function, but it crashed when I tried to get a snapshot from the newValue arg:

https://codesandbox.io/p/devbox/sharp-cherry-6fc4pv?workspaceId=ws_V6MwkdyBVdYpA4KMGgF9f5

import { getSnapshot, types } from "mobx-state-tree";
import { observe } from "mobx";

const Tweet = types
  .model("Tweet", {
    body: types.string,
    read: false,
  })
  .actions((tweet) => ({
    toggle() {
      tweet.read = !tweet.read;
    },
  }));

const TwitterStore = types
  .model("TwitterStore", {
    tweets: types.map(Tweet),
  })
  .actions((store) => ({
    add(id, tw) {
      store.tweets.set(id, tw);
    },
  }));

const twitterStore = TwitterStore.create();

observe(twitterStore.tweets, (ch) => {
  try {
    getSnapshot(ch.newValue); // 🐞 this will crash
    console.log(`change snapshot ok`);
  } catch (e) {
    console.error(`change ${ch.type} ${ch.name} crash ${e}`);
  }
});

const id = "foo";

twitterStore.add(
  "foo",
  Tweet.create({
    body: "asda",
  })
);

try {
  getSnapshot(twitterStore.tweets.get("foo"));
  console.log(`get snapshot ok`);
} catch (e) {
  console.error(`get crash ${e}`);
}

How to get snapshot from the observe's newValue?

[coolsoftwaretyler]

Hey @n9 - thanks for the bug report.

Can you please make your reproduction sandbox public? I can't view it right now.

[n9]

@coolsoftwaretyler Done.

[coolsoftwaretyler]

Good catch @n9. Looks like you're right.

The quickest patch here would be for us to update the typings to reflect that it doesn't exist.

As for using observe - have you tried with reaction instead? Using observer is an anti-pattern in MobX

[n9]

@coolsoftwaretyler How can I use reaction on an observable map to get key and value when the map changes?

[coolsoftwaretyler]

@n9 - I think something like this would work:

import { types } from "mobx-state-tree";
import { reaction } from "mobx";

const Tweet = types
  .model("Tweet", {
    body: types.string,
    read: false, // automatically inferred as type "boolean" with default "false"
  })
  .actions((tweet) => ({
    toggle() {
      tweet.read = !tweet.read;
    },
  }));

const TwitterStore = types
  .model("TwitterStore", {
    tweets: types.map(Tweet),
  })
  .actions((self) => ({
    createTweet() {
      self.tweets.set("1", { body: "Hello" });
    },
  }));

// create an instance from a snapshot
const twitterStore = TwitterStore.create();

reaction(
  () => Array.from(twitterStore.tweets.entries()),
  (entries, previousEntries) => {
    console.log("Tweets changed:");
    console.log("Current entries:", entries);
    console.log("Previous entries:", previousEntries);
  }
);

twitterStore.createTweet();

I see this output:

Here is a codesandbox.

[n9]

@coolsoftwaretyler But it will simply dump all entries.

import { types } from "mobx-state-tree";
import { reaction } from "mobx";

const Tweet = types
  .model("Tweet", {
    body: types.string,
    read: false, // automatically inferred as type "boolean" with default "false"
  })
  .actions((tweet) => ({
    toggle() {
      tweet.read = !tweet.read;
    },
  }));

const TwitterStore = types
  .model("TwitterStore", {
    tweets: types.map(Tweet),
  })
  .actions((self) => ({
    createTweet(id, body) {
      self.tweets.set(id, { body });
    },
  }));

let i = 0;
// create an instance from a snapshot
const twitterStore = TwitterStore.create({
  tweets: Object.fromEntries(
    [...new Array(100000)].map(() => [
      `key${i++}`,
      {
        body: `body${i}`,
      },
    ])
  ),
});

reaction(
  () => Array.from(twitterStore.tweets.entries()),
  (entries, previousEntries) => {
    console.log("Tweets changed:");
    console.log("Current entries:", entries);
    console.log("Previous entries:", previousEntries);
  }
);

twitterStore.createTweet(`key${i++}`, `body${i}`);

Tweets changed: Current entries: (100001) [Array(2), Array(2), Array(2), Array(2), Array(2), …] Previous entries: (100000) [Array(2), Array(2), Array(2), Array(2), Array(2), …]

How can I get only the changed entries? This will require comparing lists.

[coolsoftwaretyler]

Ah I see what you mean. This is probably a good use case for a patch listener:

import { types, onPatch } from "mobx-state-tree";
import { reaction } from "mobx";

const Tweet = types
  .model("Tweet", {
    body: types.string,
    read: false, // automatically inferred as type "boolean" with default "false"
  })
  .actions((tweet) => ({
    toggle() {
      tweet.read = !tweet.read;
    },
  }));

const TwitterStore = types
  .model("TwitterStore", {
    tweets: types.map(Tweet),
  })
  .actions((self) => ({
    createTweet() {
      self.tweets.set("1", { body: "Hello" });
    },
  }));

// create an instance from a snapshot
const twitterStore = TwitterStore.create();

onPatch(twitterStore, (patch) => {
  console.log(patch);
});

twitterStore.createTweet();

You'll get output like:

[n9]

@coolsoftwaretyler I checked the source code. Patches are generated using MobX's observe function:

https://github.com/mobxjs/mobx-state-tree/blob/05c6a3e70cff29854d574fab0ddf99cf4e7d6f9d/src/types/complex-types/map.ts#L309

https://github.com/mobxjs/mobx-state-tree/blob/05c6a3e70cff29854d574fab0ddf99cf4e7d6f9d/src/types/complex-types/map.ts#L387-L424

I found out how to get the snapshot with observe function:

• not getSnapshot(ch.newValue)
• but ch.newValue.snapshot

[n9]

P.S. Why is change.oldValue.die() only called on "delete" and not on "update" (in MapType.didChange)?

[coolsoftwaretyler]

P.S. Why is change.oldValue.die() only called on "delete" and not on "update" (in MapType.didChange)?

It's hard to say "why" for some of these implementation details. I'm far removed from the original writing of that

Could be an oversight, or perhaps it's not necessary for some reason. I'd be happy to review a PR that changes this, and we could test it out and check for any problems.

[n9]

The commit (for reference): https://github.com/mobxjs/mobx-state-tree/commit/fd6d83282245dc46802a64a5a81e8427935f4bb6