phishing icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
phishing copied to clipboard

jotform.com (whitelist)

Open spirillen opened this issue 10 months ago • 8 comments

Pull Request: Whitelisting of .jotform.com

This pull request aims to whitelist the domain .jotform.com as part of our ongoing efforts to enhance the integrity of our phishing database.

Related Issue: Phishing.Database Issue #1091

Current Status: This PR is currently on hold as I am engaging with the administrators of jotform.com to encourage adherence to the relevant RFC standards concerning HTTP server responses.

Technical Context

In accordance with RFC 7231, which outlines the semantics and content of HTTP/1.1, it is crucial for web servers to return appropriate HTTP status codes that accurately reflect the outcome of the request. For instance, the use of standard response codes such as 200 OK, 404 Not Found, and 500 Internal Server Error is essential for proper client-server communication and for ensuring that automated systems can effectively interpret server responses.

The current HTTP response behavior of jotform.com does not fully comply with these standards, which may lead to misinterpretations by clients and could potentially compromise the security measures we are implementing.

I am advocating for the following actions from the jotform.com team:

  1. Review and Update HTTP Response Codes: Ensure that all server responses align with the expected codes as defined in RFC 7231 and other relevant RFCs, such as RFC 2616 for HTTP/1.1.

  2. Implement Consistent Error Handling: Establish a consistent approach to error handling that provides clear and actionable feedback to clients, thereby improving the overall user experience and security posture.

By adhering to these standards, jotform.com can enhance its interoperability with various clients and services, ultimately contributing to a more secure and reliable web environment.

I will keep this PR on hold until we can achieve a satisfactory resolution with the jotform.com team regarding their HTTP response compliance. Thank you for your understanding and support in this matter.

ATT: @cigdemtosun

spirillen avatar Feb 12 '25 17:02 spirillen

falsos posivos amormisericordioso.cl elmejorplao.cl donaggio.cl

alphanet31 avatar Feb 27 '25 23:02 alphanet31

@alphanet31 please report false positives here one by one https://github.com/Phishing-Database/Phishing.Database/issues

DavidOsipov avatar Feb 28 '25 06:02 DavidOsipov

The website is still uses 200 code for everything.

Proof

image

DavidOsipov avatar Feb 28 '25 06:02 DavidOsipov

The website is still uses 200 code for everything.

Thanks a lot for your followup, I just noticed, come to think... is this in reality yet another problem by using Cloudflare as server manager and network controllers of a domain?

Why on earth should anyone, by their free will, wants to reply a http 404 with http 200?? that don't make any seance to me.

image

spirillen avatar Feb 28 '25 09:02 spirillen

@spirillen I've tested my small website, which uses Cloudflare as reverse proxy - everything is ok. Of course, my static website, hosted on Cloudflare pages, has other codes - but I guess I can fix it too.

Details

image

DavidOsipov avatar Feb 28 '25 16:02 DavidOsipov

@spirillen I've tested my small website, which uses Cloudflare.

Oh, why did you have to ruin my fondness for you? 😭 😭 😭 😭 😭 Was that intentional?

  • https://kb.mypdns.org/articles/MPDNS-A-4/CloudFlare – that’s a twist in your life that you really need to sort out quickly.
  • https://kb.mypdns.org/articles/MPDNS-A-2/Fundamental-human-rights

You do realise that CrimeFlare and

with a soft spot for cybersecurity

are heading in completely different directions, don’t you?

spirillen avatar Feb 28 '25 20:02 spirillen

Man, privacy != security :) There are some websites, that can be hosted at Cloudflare - let it be.

Also can't access your links @spirillen :

Details

image

DavidOsipov avatar Mar 01 '25 07:03 DavidOsipov

Also can't access your links

Of course not, I do not support spyware... Try a Fox ESR and you will pass with flying color...

map $http_user_agent $blocked_agent {
    default 0;

    # Browsers Allowed
    ~*Chrome 1; # Google Chrome
    ~*Deno 0;
    ~*Mastodon 0;
    ~*MisskeyMediaProxy 0; # Misskey Media Proxy
    ~*Mozilla 0;
    ~*Takahe 0;
    ~*TorBrowser 0; # Tor Browser

...

    # Block command-line tools
    ~*curl 0; # cURL
    ~*wget 0; # Wget
    ~*lynx 0; # Lynx
}

spirillen avatar Mar 01 '25 09:03 spirillen

Closing.

Domain(s) or IP(s) not found in issue message or title.

-- We appreciate your help in refining this. Please let us know if anything seems incorrect.

phishing-database-bot avatar Apr 10 '25 21:04 phishing-database-bot

Closing.

Domain(s) or IP(s) not found in issue message or title.

-- We appreciate your help in refining this. Please let us know if anything seems incorrect.

What???

spirillen avatar Apr 11 '25 05:04 spirillen

Closing.

Domain(s) or IP(s) not found in issue message or title.

-- We appreciate your help in refining this. Please let us know if anything seems incorrect.

phishing-database-bot avatar Apr 11 '25 05:04 phishing-database-bot

@funilrys @phishing-database-bot This script do not seems to work properly... I stop checking closed issues by this script and leaves it to you, to revisit ALL closed issues by @phishing-database-bot as most of them seems to be closed on false grounds.

phishing_database/ALL-phishing-links.csv:jotform.com
phishing_database/ALL-phishing-links.csv:app.jotform.com
phishing_database/ALL-phishing-links.csv:form.jotform.com
phishing_database/ALL-phishing-links.csv:www.jotform.com
phishing_database/phishing.database/domain.csv:app.jotform.com
phishing_database/phishing.database/domain.csv:form.jotform.com
phishing_database/phishing.database/domain.csv:jotform.com

spirillen avatar Apr 11 '25 05:04 spirillen

Closing.

Domain(s) or IP(s) not found in issue message or title.

-- We appreciate your help in refining this. Please let us know if anything seems incorrect.

phishing-database-bot avatar Apr 11 '25 05:04 phishing-database-bot

Closing.

Domain(s) or IP(s) not found in the Phishing.Database project: tools.ietf.org, jotform.com.

-- We appreciate your help in refining this. Please let us know if anything seems incorrect.

phishing-database-bot avatar Apr 26 '25 18:04 phishing-database-bot