minetest_game icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
minetest_game copied to clipboard

Bring back the classic wood and stone sounds.

Open Tim79000 opened this issue 2 years ago • 8 comments

The new sounds are particular ear grading due to the Minetest sound system making sounds a bit too compressed sounding. The original sounds didn't have this issue due to them not being that crisp. Not to mention I just miss the original sounds. :(

Tim79000 avatar Feb 21 '23 00:02 Tim79000

You should be able to look through the git history and get those files, and put them in a mod that depends on default to use the old sounds.

NathanSalapat avatar Feb 21 '23 01:02 NathanSalapat

Yeah, but the issue is that their are no such thing as, replacing sounds with texture packs, I get they are texture packs, but Minecraft has that capability, why can't Minetest?

Tim79000 avatar Feb 21 '23 04:02 Tim79000

Sound packs.

rollerozxa avatar Feb 21 '23 08:02 rollerozxa

Are the "new" sounds really a major regression?

Updating sounds / textures passes as maintenance, so a PR could pass, given it provides sufficient rationale / poll / whatever that reverting is indeed the way to go.

appgurueu avatar Feb 21 '23 14:02 appgurueu

Sound packs.

Sound-packs can only provide non-existing sounds, but not replace sounds.


Btw. I've opened a similar issue some time ago (#2755), but it was closed by paramat.

Desour avatar Feb 21 '23 16:02 Desour

Feel free to open a PR.

appgurueu avatar Feb 21 '23 17:02 appgurueu

How about adding shade packs too or texture-shade packs.

ixPost avatar Apr 30 '23 17:04 ixPost

The engine supports sound packs as far as I know. Still it might make sense to have sensible default sounds, esp. as UX support for sound packs is poor IIRC.

appgurueu avatar Apr 30 '23 18:04 appgurueu