fluentui-system-icons icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
fluentui-system-icons copied to clipboard

Caret Directions

Open nor0x opened this issue 3 years ago • 7 comments

Is there a reason why there is only one direction for a diagonal pointing caret? I have also noticed that Caret and Caret Down Left are identical icons where Down Left actually points Down Right as highlighted in the screenshot.

image

Of course this could be achieved by rotating the icon, but it would be nice to have built-in support for Carets, Chevron, Arrows, Circle Arrows and similar icons pointing to all directions:

  • up
  • up-right
  • right
  • down-right
  • down
  • down-left
  • left
  • up-left

nor0x avatar Jun 06 '21 09:06 nor0x

Thanks for bringing this up. The direction of Caret Down Left, as-is, will be corrected in a coming update and we will try to add the other directions for it. "Caret" is an erroneous holdover that we will remove in a couple of weeks when we do a renaming/deprecation pass.

spencer-nelson avatar Jun 07 '21 17:06 spencer-nelson

thanks for the info @spencer-nelson !

"Caret" is an erroneous holdover that we will remove in a couple of weeks when we do a renaming/deprecation pass.

will there be an alternative for "Caret"?

nor0x avatar Jun 07 '21 19:06 nor0x

I believe that if all 8 directions for Caret exist there will not be a need for "Caret" so there won't be an alternative planned for now. Of course, every time I say that someone gives me another opportunity to eat my words, but at least for right now it's not planned.

spencer-nelson avatar Jun 07 '21 19:06 spencer-nelson

I believe that if all 8 directions for Caret exist there will not be a need for "Caret" so there won't be an alternative planned for now. Of course, every time I say that someone gives me another opportunity to eat my words, but at least for right now it's not planned.

How about for RtL scenarios?

mdtauk avatar Jun 07 '21 20:06 mdtauk

Given that the carats (and other arrows) are centered within the icon, we don't expect a need to differentiate for RTL/LTR localization. If you have an example otherwise, please share it, as I'm sure I suffer from perspective bias to at least a certain degree.

spencer-nelson avatar Jun 07 '21 20:06 spencer-nelson

Given that the carats (and other arrows) are centered within the icon, we don't expect a need to differentiate for RTL/LTR localization. If you have an example otherwise, please share it, as I'm sure I suffer from perspective bias to at least a certain degree.

The 4 cardinal directions are present, but the Down Right has no Down Left, which would be used if the UI was Right to Left.

image I know this is an outdated example, but its the only one that springs to mind

I guess it may be more a sense of completeness that makes it odd there is no Up Left, Up Right, and Down Left - in that set of Carets 😂

mdtauk avatar Jun 07 '21 20:06 mdtauk

Ahh. Yes, as mentioned we are planning to add the other, currently missing, directions that would fill it as 8 directions to complete the set as you noted.

spencer-nelson avatar Jun 07 '21 21:06 spencer-nelson