PowerToys icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
PowerToys copied to clipboard

Mouse Without Borders for Android and other OSs

Open kk-spartans opened this issue 1 year ago • 26 comments

Description of the new feature / enhancement

I would like mouse without borders to be available for android; It would be the exact same thing

Scenario when this would be used?

I always have my phone next to my PC and I would like to not need to
always reach out for it when I need to use it

Supporting information

No response

kk-spartans avatar May 25 '23 11:05 kk-spartans

I'd also love to see this, this would be a great way to compete with "Universal Control" on macOS/iPad, beyond just Surface tablets, and it seems like a great extension of the "Phone Link" app's work towards integrating Android and Windows together.

Perhaps the PowerToys team could work with the Phone Link team to make this work through their app as an "Experimental" feature, or perhaps via a new area in the settings called "PowerToys," so that the PowerToys team themselves don't have to worry about maintaining a separate Android app.

I picked up a Pixel Tablet last month, and with it set up just below my monitor, I'd love to be able to seamlessly control it with my keyboard and mouse.

It'd also be awesome if this could work with iOS, but I agree Android should be the priority.


This would be better as a new issue, I'm sure, but somewhat related, it'd be awesome if PowerToys could support something like "Sidecar" on macOS/iPad. Now that I think about it though, I think this is already built in to Phone Link for Samsung phones. Maybe we'll get wider support eventually...

JacobDB avatar Jul 03 '23 14:07 JacobDB

Linux, iPad, ....

crutkas avatar Jul 31 '23 18:07 crutkas

I second this for linux

Luk164 avatar Aug 09 '23 09:08 Luk164

Would be great to have this possibility :)

nightsparc avatar Aug 15 '23 16:08 nightsparc

Hi.

Just like a comment, you can use https://github.com/Genymobile/scrcpy to display and control android your android devices, i mean, will be great that Mouse without borders could integrate the feature, but for now you could use the other project.

image

uebmaster avatar Aug 15 '23 17:08 uebmaster

@uebmaster while Scrcpy can be used to control an Android device from Windows, it can only do so through screen mirroring, so it's not really a good alternative to Mouse Without Borders, which essentially lets you share a keyboard and mouse between two devices. Essentially, instead of screen mirroring, you instead move your cursor between devices, as if they were one device.

Scrcpy is fine for some use cases, but it's really not the same thing.

JacobDB avatar Aug 15 '23 19:08 JacobDB

I know it, i've used it synergy in the past, but i said scrcpy just to "fix" the necesity in the moment, i think that is posible to use mouse without borders and scrcpy at same time and resolve the problem at least temporaly.


De: Jacob Bearce @.> Enviado: martes, 15 de agosto de 2023 01:26 p. m. Para: microsoft/PowerToys @.> Cc: Uebmaster @.>; Mention @.> Asunto: Re: [microsoft/PowerToys] Mouse Without Borders for Android and other OSs (Issue #26296)

@uebmasterhttps://github.com/uebmaster while Scrcpy can be used to control an Android device from Windows, it can only do so through screen mirroring, so it's not really a good alternative to Mouse Without Borders, which essentially lets you share a keyboard and mouse between two devices. Essentially, instead of screen mirroring, you instead move your cursor between devices, as if they were one device.

Scrcpy is fine for some use cases, but it's really not the same thing.

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/microsoft/PowerToys/issues/26296#issuecomment-1679477758, or unsubscribehttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ABKOYQVJZTYIO377ISYQL43XVPEMZANCNFSM6AAAAAAYOWC624. You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: @.***>

uebmaster avatar Aug 15 '23 22:08 uebmaster

+1 for this feature

WhoMI7 avatar Sep 14 '23 10:09 WhoMI7

I agree that this feature would be very valuable for linux and macOS

emendoza2 avatar Sep 14 '23 13:09 emendoza2

I would love to see this enhancement, especially for Android. It would also be convenient if it doesn't depend on the local network, since there are a lot of moments where I'm not able to connect to the same network as my windows device. If it could work over WAN or Bluetooth (or at least have mobile hotspot discovery support), then this would be ideal! Though the security question is the follow up issue to that, I might imagine.

noahstreller avatar Sep 14 '23 15:09 noahstreller

I would love this just so I can use my phone as a second screen for my pc for increased productivity, not just for controlling android.

TLCPlusPlus avatar Sep 18 '23 17:09 TLCPlusPlus

I see #26630 was merged to this ticket.

Just to be clear, as most of the discussion here is for mobile devices, another use case, and for me a stronger one, would be support for MacOS and Linux.

Context would be consulting type roles where I have a work device and a client device running different OS. As an example, I have a Windows based work laptop and the client has just issued a MacBook.

Also, may not be directly relevant but for the use case or mobile devices as a second screen I know GNOME desktop Linux is able to leverage RDP in reverse where the mobile client RDPs to the target desktop machine but instead of remote control it appears as a second screen. Feels like Windows own implementation of RDP should handle this use case?

GingerGraham avatar Sep 21 '23 09:09 GingerGraham

Huge Fan and also subscribing to this feature request. My usecase would be Android < > win.

How is the currently state regarding this?

Whats needed to make this real next?

tobiasgraeber avatar Dec 07 '23 20:12 tobiasgraeber

me too, I need this I have been searching for something like this for a while but most of what I found has been abandoned. I really hope this feature gets more attention, my use case is also between windows and android.

Galaxy0Gamer avatar Dec 29 '23 17:12 Galaxy0Gamer

I need this too, for now I'm using https://github.com/debauchee/barrier for that kind of behaviour. It's not for android though

Shinbly avatar Jan 08 '24 09:01 Shinbly

Until this feature comes out i think just using a multi channel keyboard and mouse would be the way to go I also don't have a Samsung phone so I can't use phone link. (I really didn't think that so many people would pay attention to this feature)

Mouse without borders is way better than a multi channel mouse. You can share clipboard and drag-and-drop files. And you can switch to other devices simply by moving cursor, not clicking a button each time.

back2yes avatar Mar 13 '24 01:03 back2yes

Are there any alternatives to 'Mouse Without Borders' available for Linux&Windows now? It would be really useful.

hatrd avatar Apr 01 '24 03:04 hatrd

Are there any alternatives to 'Mouse Without Borders' available for Linux&Windows now? It would be really useful.

Synergy 3 is pretty good Although it ain't free, but it is a one time purchase

ArjixWasTaken avatar Apr 01 '24 05:04 ArjixWasTaken

Are there any alternatives to 'Mouse Without Borders' available for Linux&Windows now? It would be really useful.

Barrier is a good one, free and open-source as well

Luk164 avatar Apr 01 '24 07:04 Luk164

Are there any alternatives to 'Mouse Without Borders' available for Linux&Windows now? It would be really useful.

Barrier is a good one, free and open-source as well

Thanks a lot, I am using it now.

hatrd avatar Apr 01 '24 07:04 hatrd

I just use scrcpy with otg. If you use my command it basically mimics the seamless switching of synergy by moving your mouse to the edge of the screen to switch devices but with this you have to click "scrcpy --otg --always-on-top --window-x=0 --window-y=350 --window-width=35 --window-height=400 --window-borderless"

Lumanac avatar Apr 22 '24 06:04 Lumanac

+2 Would love this to control my iPad and Mac, Both of which I have on the same desk as my PC which is my main, at the moment. Was a super nice experience when I had 2 PC's on my desk. I'm on the edge of buying sharemouse or synergy after struggling to make barrier work well a few months ago. Trying again now, but I've wasted a lot of time with this issue.

crispearson avatar Jun 12 '24 13:06 crispearson

Guys i finally found the solution. It's made by another developer though. https://github.com/rohitsangwan01/uni_control_hub Check this out guys!

Lumanac avatar Aug 05 '24 07:08 Lumanac

Guys i finally found the solution. It's made by another developer though. https://github.com/rohitsangwan01/uni_control_hub Check this out guys!

Interesting, but other than the nice UI, what extra functionality does this bring over say barrier?

Luk164 avatar Aug 05 '24 15:08 Luk164