EdgeML icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
EdgeML copied to clipboard

Why is the GRNN much slower than a GRU

Open jambo6 opened this issue 3 years ago • 1 comments

from torch import nn
from rnn import FastGRNNCUDA

x = torch.randn((8192, 4, 512)).cuda()
h0 = torch.zeros((4, 512)).cuda()
    
gru = nn.GRU(512, 512, batch_first=False).cuda()
grnn = FastGRNNCUDA(512, 512, batch_first=False).cuda()

Timing (with proper cuda synchronisation) gives a loop time of 0.1s for the GRU and 0.35s for the GRNN. Am I doing something wrong, surely the GRNN should be at least on par with the GRU since it is less operations.

jambo6 avatar Nov 22 '22 13:11 jambo6

Hi,

Thanks for the timing numbers. IIRC, I don't think we optimized GRNN to the level of inbuilt GRU and that shows evidently here. The speedups are obvious when you use GRU and GRNN from our own naive implementations.

Aditya

adityakusupati avatar Nov 22 '22 20:11 adityakusupati