GmsCore icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
GmsCore copied to clipboard

Support Google Prompt for 2-step verification

Open t-m-w opened this issue 1 year ago • 16 comments

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe. When logging in to a Google account, Google automatically adds the device as one that is capable of receiving Google Prompt for two-step verification purposes, but when Google tries to show a prompt, nothing happens.

Describe the solution you'd like Supporting Google Prompt would make this more or less a non-issue.

Describe alternatives you've considered Could see if there is a way to make Google not add the device as a prompt device.

t-m-w avatar Jun 06 '24 16:06 t-m-w

This feature is one of the last ones, that MicroG is missing in order to fully replace GMS for daily use for me.

More disturbing is the fact that you need to enable "Register device" to have your "Receive push notifications" enabled, but when you register the device, Google thinks that it must authenticate you by the Google Prompt and you only have two options to authenticate:

  1. Use another device to receive that Prompt
  2. Use TOTP codes to authenticate

Both of these options are rather disturbing.

malsatin avatar Aug 27 '24 12:08 malsatin

This needs to happen, I would be happy to help out with working on this if I knew where to start researching

Sense101 avatar Oct 15 '24 14:10 Sense101

Is there any update on this? It has become a pain lately since I cannot change the sensitive data on my google account without using this verification method because they give me no alternative, and I have no devices with google play services on it so I have been locked out of that part of my own account because of it.

RedCyberPandaz avatar Feb 12 '25 22:02 RedCyberPandaz

Hopefully solve this problem in version 0.3.7.

yangyang628 avatar Feb 15 '25 11:02 yangyang628

I got the prompt when i installed microG as user app or through kernelSU but yesterday i tried to flash minmocroG in recovery and i got this problem too. I noticed that applications can register directly to GCM without prompt.

yoshiz44 avatar Feb 28 '25 06:02 yoshiz44

Ended up going back to play services because of this, help

lucasdaweb95 avatar Mar 11 '25 02:03 lucasdaweb95

The last time I saved some "backup codes" to access Google was a long time ago, and when I try them, Google refuses them all. I'm really scared about losing access to my account now that Google is pushing Google Prompt so hard (no text message option, it's greyed out). Now "Provider for Google Calendar" in Thunderbird is asking to re-authorize my Google account access, and I can't do it!

Is there any safe way forward? What's this "hopefully solved in 0.3.7" business? Is the prompt going to work soon?

Is there any other workaround so I don't lose my Google account just in case?

wolftune avatar Mar 21 '25 00:03 wolftune

You could save an authenticator code That works for me but authorizing apps requires google prompt, no exception

Sent from Proton Mail Android

-------- Original Message -------- On 3/20/25 9:42 PM, Aaron Wolf wrote:

The last time I saved some "backup codes" to access Google was a long time ago, and when I try them, Google refuses them all. I'm really scared about losing access to my account now that Google is pushing Google Prompt so hard (no text message option, it's greyed out). Now "Provider for Google Calendar" in Thunderbird is asking to re-authorize my Google account access, and I can't do it!

Is there any safe way forward? What's this "hopefully solved in 0.3.7" business? Is the prompt going to work soon?

Is there any other workaround so I don't lose my Google account just in case?

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe. You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: @.***>

[wolftune]wolftune left a comment (microg/GmsCore#2397)

The last time I saved some "backup codes" to access Google was a long time ago, and when I try them, Google refuses them all. I'm really scared about losing access to my account now that Google is pushing Google Prompt so hard (no text message option, it's greyed out). Now "Provider for Google Calendar" in Thunderbird is asking to re-authorize my Google account access, and I can't do it!

Is there any safe way forward? What's this "hopefully solved in 0.3.7" business? Is the prompt going to work soon?

Is there any other workaround so I don't lose my Google account just in case?

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe. You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: @.***>

lucasdaweb95 avatar Mar 21 '25 01:03 lucasdaweb95

Google won't let me update authenticator codes without first doing the Google Prompt validation itself.

Now that I think about it, what would happen if I lost my phone? Surely whatever that process is needs to work to not lose my Google account. Is it safe enough to sign out of my Google account in MicroG? Will that lead to being able to use back-up authentication methods?

wolftune avatar Mar 21 '25 16:03 wolftune

Any updates on this? It really is a problem as I happen to be dealing with logging in and out of my Google account quite often and I'm afraid my current workaround might stop working soon.

Edit: It already has stopped working. I was using the recovery option to get an SMS code.

ItzELECTR0 avatar Apr 01 '25 07:04 ItzELECTR0

It's been almost a year, is there any update to this? I have had to entirely stop using my google account for anything because I can't get into certain parts of it.

RedCyberPandaz avatar Apr 23 '25 00:04 RedCyberPandaz

Before the two-step verification is resolved. If you frequently log in or log out of your account. You can turn on the profile - Select (Security) to enable the alternate verification code function. Save the backup verification code to your phone. When logging in, you can enter the backup verification code to log in to your Google account. There are ten verification codes in each group, and one backup verification code will be invalid once logged in. So remember to update regularly. This problem can be solved. This is the best solution at present. There is no other way.

yangyang628 avatar Apr 23 '25 04:04 yangyang628

there's also the authenticator code, i use that most of the time

Sent from Proton Mail Android

-------- Original Message -------- On 4/23/25 1:49 AM, yangyang628 wrote:

Before the two-step verification is resolved. If you frequently log in or log out of your account. You can turn on the profile - Select (Security) to enable the alternate verification code function. Save the backup verification code to your phone. When logging in, you can enter the backup verification code to log in to your Google account. There are ten verification codes in each group, and one backup verification code will be invalid once logged in. So remember to update regularly. This problem can be solved. This is the best solution at present. There is no other way.

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe. You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: @.***>

yangyang628 left a comment (microg/GmsCore#2397)

Before the two-step verification is resolved. If you frequently log in or log out of your account. You can turn on the profile - Select (Security) to enable the alternate verification code function. Save the backup verification code to your phone. When logging in, you can enter the backup verification code to log in to your Google account. There are ten verification codes in each group, and one backup verification code will be invalid once logged in. So remember to update regularly. This problem can be solved. This is the best solution at present. There is no other way.

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe. You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: @.***>

lucasdaweb95 avatar Apr 23 '25 09:04 lucasdaweb95

In my experience, Google doesn't allow the alternative options like authenticator code or backup codes as long as it recognizes that I'm logged in on the phone in MicroG. Is it safe for me to log out of my Google account in MicroG as a way to make Google accept the alternative options?

wolftune avatar Apr 23 '25 14:04 wolftune

Yes, alternative methods work just fine in my experience

malsatin avatar Apr 23 '25 22:04 malsatin

My fear is that Google will make it harder for me to get into my account on my phone if I sign out… because I'm now feeling more paranoid about Google in general (and I really need to more figure out how to escape fully).

wolftune avatar Apr 23 '25 22:04 wolftune