picard-plugins icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
picard-plugins copied to clipboard

Published 20 hours ago • verified publisher icon metabrainz

Format performsers splits "lead vocals" into "lead" and "vocals".

Open phw opened this issue 4 years ago • 2 comments

Using the "Format performer" tag loading e.g. https://musicbrainz.org/recording/e55e5bca-7fe2-436b-9afa-a5338fae32b6 the "lead vocal" relationship gets truend into two relationships, one for "lead" and one for "vocals". Same happens for "background vocals". I used the standard settings of the plugin

@rdswift Can you take a look?

phw avatar May 11 '20 07:05 phw

I can't seem to reproduce it here using the new 0.7 version. Following are the settings I used (which I think are the defaults -- I pulled them from the code), and the results:

image

image

Can you please confirm the settings that you used and the results? Thanks.

rdswift avatar May 11 '20 15:05 rdswift

Or are we thinking that there needs to be an option to treat "lead vocals" and "background vocals" each as their own keys rather than as a "vocals" key with "lead" and "background" descriptors, so they would be treated differently from other vocals like "soprano vocals"?

rdswift avatar May 11 '20 16:05 rdswift