🐞 [Bug]: MQTT does not connect with TLS enabled

[Flothoger]

Firmware Version

2.3.7

What did you do?

I am running a selfhosted Mosquitto server with LetsEncrypt TLS certificates. Connecting a generic MQTT Client, like MQTTX, works fine with not TLS / SSL errors.

When connecting using the iOS or macOS app the connection times out. In the app I get the following error: kCFStreamErrorDomain SSL-Error -9806. When looking at the Mosquitto logs I see:

1715074957: New connection from 10.0.1.82:51076 on port 8883.
1715075025: Client <unknown> disconnected: Protocol error.
1715075408: New connection from <IP-removed>:56488 on port 8883.
1715075442: Client <unknown> has exceeded timeout, disconnecting.

I tried with TLS v1.3, v1.2 and v1.1. Changing it on the server side makes no difference. Also Meshtastic does not announce a Client-ID to the MQTT server. I am not sure wether this might be a bug or user error, but since the connection is working with any MQTT client other than Meshtastic I think it might be either something with the app itself or how iOS handles TLS traffic.

Expected Behavior

The MQTTS connection should succeed with no errors. On the Mosquitto server I would expect log entries like this:

1715075231: New connection from 10.0.1.82:51092 on port 8883.
1715075231: New client connected from 10.0.1.82:51092 as mqttx_24b4f0dd (p5, c1, k60, u'test').

Current Behavior

No response

Participation

• [ ] I am willing to submit a pull request for this issue.

Additional comments

Node config:

# start of Meshtastic configure yaml
channel_url: <removed>
config:
  bluetooth:
    enabled: true
    fixedPin: 123456
  device:
    nodeInfoBroadcastSecs: 10800
    serialEnabled: true
  display:
    gpsFormat: UTM
    screenOnSecs: 900
  lora:
    hopLimit: 3
    region: EU_868
    sx126xRxBoostedGain: true
    txEnabled: true
    txPower: 27
    usePreset: true
  network:
    ntpServer: 0.pool.ntp.org
  position:
    broadcastSmartMinimumDistance: 100
    broadcastSmartMinimumIntervalSecs: 30
    gpsUpdateInterval: 120
    positionBroadcastSecs: 900
    positionBroadcastSmartEnabled: true
    positionFlags: 811
  power:
    lsSecs: 300
    minWakeSecs: 10
    sdsSecs: 4294967295
    waitBluetoothSecs: 60
location:
  alt: 103
  lat: <removed>
  lon: <removed>
module_config:
  ambientLighting:
    blue: 124
    current: 10
    green: 122
    red: 109
  detectionSensor:
    detectionTriggeredHigh: true
    minimumBroadcastSecs: 45
  mqtt:
    address: mqtt.<removed>.de
    enabled: true
    encryptionEnabled: true
    mapReportSettings:
      positionPrecision: 12
    password: test1234
    proxyToClientEnabled: true
    root: msh/EU_868
    tlsEnabled: true
    username: test
  neighborInfo:
    updateInterval: 900
  serial:
    enabled: true
  telemetry:
    deviceUpdateInterval: 900
    environmentMeasurementEnabled: true
    environmentScreenEnabled: true
    environmentUpdateInterval: 900
owner: Test
owner_short: Test