SimpMusic icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
SimpMusic copied to clipboard

Possible to align Favorite (SimpMusic) with Liked Music (Youtube)?

Open Bwangster12 opened this issue 1 year ago • 7 comments

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe. New to SimpMusic, but I'm finding when logged in to Youtube and I press the heart button to Favorite a song, it goes into a separate local playlist rather than into the Liked Music playlist synced to Youtube. That Favorite playlist also doesn't show up in Android Auto.

Describe the solution you'd like Can the heart button/Favorite just save the song to your Liked Music that's integrated into Youtube?

Describe alternatives you've considered Add an option just to save directly to the Youtube Music Liked Music, rather than having to add to a playlist.

Bwangster12 avatar Dec 18 '24 13:12 Bwangster12

You can directly add the song to YouTube's "likes" with that button.

Image

mart-238 avatar Mar 01 '25 03:03 mart-238

Why is there a heart button to save to the local favorite and a plus to save it to Youtube? Why not just align the lists?

Bwangster12 avatar Jun 02 '25 19:06 Bwangster12

When I design this app, I want to make local first and YouTube Music is the optional.

maxrave-dev avatar Jun 03 '25 04:06 maxrave-dev

"+" button is inspired by Spotify. Instead of Favorite button, it is "Add to YouTube Liked" button

maxrave-dev avatar Jun 03 '25 04:06 maxrave-dev

Maybe a better option would be to have a toggle?
e.g. remove the "+", make a setting that toggles the behaviour in simpmusic settings.
I think less is more in terms of getting a cleaner UI.

CrazyWolf13 avatar Sep 03 '25 06:09 CrazyWolf13

@maxrave-dev demand seems to be here, can you look into possible options?

CrazyWolf13 avatar Sep 03 '25 06:09 CrazyWolf13

Maybe this can benefit from a toggle too: https://github.com/maxrave-dev/SimpMusic/issues/629 , e.g. the same for playlists

CrazyWolf13 avatar Sep 03 '25 07:09 CrazyWolf13