E5108: Error executing lua ... Invalid 'group': 'JABS'

[Sanart0]

Hello, i have a problem with JABS, when i run it (like :JABSOpen), i get an error.

For plugins i use Lazy.

This is my neovim lua config for JABS:

...
{"matbme/JABS.nvim",
	keys = {
		{ "<leader>b", "<cmd>JABSOpen<CR>" },
	},
	config = function ()
		require("jabs").setup ({
			position = {"center", "center"},
			border = 'single',
			keymap = {
				close = "d",
				h_split = "h",
				v_split = "v",
				preview = "p",
			},
			use_devicons = true
		})
end},
...

This is error message:

E5108: Error executing lua ~/.local/share/nvim/lazy/JABS.nvim/lua/jabs.lua:546: Invalid 'group': 'JABS'                
stack traceback:
        [C]: in function 'nvim_clear_autocmds'
        ~.local/share/nvim/lazy/JABS.nvim/lua/jabs.lua:546: in function 'close'
        ~.local/share/nvim/lazy/JABS.nvim/lua/jabs.lua:621: in function 'open'
        [string ":lua"]:1: in main chunk

[matbme]

I just tested your config and it works for me. What version of Neovim are you on? Also, are you using the latest version of the plugin?

[Sanart0]

I use nvim v0.9.0, and the plugin is latest JABS version. Also maybe it will be helpful, OS is Manjaro 22

[matbme]

I haven't tested JABS with lazy.nvim yet, maybe the lazy loading is causing issues. Could you try setting the plugin to use lazy = false?

[Sanart0]

I tried, and got the same error, but i think that problem is not with lazy, because my friend have Arch and he have a same config with JABS and lazy and it works well.

[AlexisFinn]

Hello. Any updates on this ? I am getting the same error, bot only on the second call. The first time I call it JABS gives me a different error that might help in determining the problem:

   Error  16:40:24 msg_show.lua_error   JABSOpen E5108: Error executing lua /home/alexis/.local/share/nvim/lazy/JABS.nvim/lua/jabs.lua:198: bad argument #1 to 'match' (string expected, got nil)
stack traceback:
	[C]: in function 'match'
	/home/alexis/.local/share/nvim/lazy/JABS.nvim/lua/jabs.lua:198: in function 'getFileSymbol'
	/home/alexis/.local/share/nvim/lazy/JABS.nvim/lua/jabs.lua:453: in function 'parseLs'
	/home/alexis/.local/share/nvim/lazy/JABS.nvim/lua/jabs.lua:587: in function 'refresh'
	/home/alexis/.local/share/nvim/lazy/JABS.nvim/lua/jabs.lua:616: in function 'open'
	[string ":lua"]:1: in main chunk
   Error  16:40:40 msg_show.lua_error   JABSOpen E5108: Error executing lua /home/alexis/.local/share/nvim/lazy/JABS.nvim/lua/jabs.lua:546: Invalid 'group': 'JABS'
stack traceback:
	[C]: in function 'nvim_clear_autocmds'
	/home/alexis/.local/share/nvim/lazy/JABS.nvim/lua/jabs.lua:546: in function 'close'
	/home/alexis/.local/share/nvim/lazy/JABS.nvim/lua/jabs.lua:621: in function 'open'
	[string ":lua"]:1: in main chunk

I have no config:

require("jabs").setup({})
local keymap = vim.api.nvim_set_keymap
keymap('n', '<F8>', ':JABSOpen<CR>', {})

But it does open an empty overlayed window in the bottom right hand, so I'm wondering if another plugin might be conflicting with the popup drawing.

[jeff-dh]

@AlexisFinn could you provide the output of :ls and :ls t for the error you reported?

[jeff-dh]

As an alternative you could check out this fork:

https://github.com/jeff-dh/expJABS.nvim

It's a refactored and enhanced version of JABS, that might not be affect by this issue.

[jeff-dh]

It makes sense that a "previous" aborted call to JABS causes the error mentioned by @Sanart0 . Since this branch of the JABS plugin uses a global state. An aborted call to JABS might cause a partially initialized global state. The second call might think the state is initialized (because a certain variable is set) and call the close function. Since the state is not initialized correctly the close call fails and causes another error (because it can not find a supposed to be registered group name that would have been registered if the first call would not have been aborted).

https://github.com/matbme/JABS.nvim/blob/b6dbd1a3e1b8cef3d6ebfafe96c2230ca341b65f/lua/jabs.lua#L615-L618 Switching the order of these three lines might(!) solve the first issue, but would also be a hack. The refresh call is what caused the error mentioned by @AlexisFinn , the set_autocmds functions registers the group name "JABS" that was not found in the error mentioned by @Sanart0.

So there would be a causing issue (like @AlexisFinn reported) which causes a error in the error handling of jabs (as reported by @Sanart0).

[AlexisFinn]

@jeff-dh sorry for late answer.

I can confirm using jeff-hd/expJABS.nvim does fix the issue.

Also I'm not sure I know what you mean by :ls and :ls t, but here's what I got right after I triggered the error:

   Error  18:06:07 msg_show.lua_error   JABSOpen E5108: Error executing lua /home/alexis/.local/share/nvim/lazy/JABS.nvim/lua/jabs.lua:198: bad argument #1 to 'match' (string expected, got nil)
stack traceback:
	[C]: in function 'match'
	/home/alexis/.local/share/nvim/lazy/JABS.nvim/lua/jabs.lua:198: in function 'getFileSymbol'
	/home/alexis/.local/share/nvim/lazy/JABS.nvim/lua/jabs.lua:453: in function 'parseLs'
	/home/alexis/.local/share/nvim/lazy/JABS.nvim/lua/jabs.lua:587: in function 'refresh'
	/home/alexis/.local/share/nvim/lazy/JABS.nvim/lua/jabs.lua:616: in function 'open'
	[string ":lua"]:1: in main chunk
18:06:16 msg_show   ls   3      "config/nvim/lua/plugin-configs/colorschemes.lua" ligne 1
  4      "config/nvim/lua/config.lua"   ligne 46
  5      "config/nvim/lua/plugin-configs/auto-session.lua" ligne 4
  6 #a   "config/nvim/lua/plugin-configs/JABS.lua" ligne 2
  7      "config/nvim/lua/plugin-configs/which-key.lua" ligne 1
18:06:20 msg_show   ls t   6 #a   "config/nvim/lua/plugin-configs/JABS.lua" il y a 15 secondes
  3      "config/nvim/lua/plugin-configs/colorschemes.lua" ligne 1
  4      "config/nvim/lua/config.lua"   ligne 46
  5      "config/nvim/lua/plugin-configs/auto-session.lua" ligne 4
  7      "config/nvim/lua/plugin-configs/which-key.lua" ligne 1

I don't know how to interpret this, I get it seems to be some kind of stack trace and if I had to guess which of the mentionned plugins in causing problems it would probably be auto-session but what do I know...

[jeff-dh]

I think you did everything right regarding the :ls command.

Does it really output ligne? Not line?

If that's the case, that's the issue! Are you running nvim in French?

Try to set the config value sort_mru = true, this might be a work around.

Anyway, if the expJABS branch solves your issue, I would suggest to just keep on going with it..... but it will have the same issue concerning line vs ligne and the sort_mru work around should work aswell. I might have a look at it and can try to add multilanguage support to expJABS.

[jeff-dh]

Yeah, the non English language of nvim is pretty sure the issue..... JABS uses a regexp that "greps" for "line" to parse the output of :ls, if nvim does not run in English... well... it can't find line and thus calls some functions with nil values which causes a crash, which causes a partially global state, which causes the other error.

[jeff-dh]

So, it turned out that the reason why expJABS is not affected by this issue is, that sort_mru = true is the default in expJABS otherwise it produces very similar issues.

I added "multi language support" to expJABS (at least for the line issue). Could you give the latest expJABS a try with explicitly setting sort_mru = false to test it and whether there are other issues concerning multi language support?

Thanks!