mastodon-ios
mastodon-ios copied to clipboard
mastodon
Re-add the "unlisted" visibility option
Apparently this was removed as per https://github.com/mastodon/mastodon-ios/issues/144, why? It's a completely valid visibility option for mastodon, all apps (web or mobile) support it.
@Gargron It seems to cause some confusion after removing the unlist option for the visibility menu.
It's not confusing that #231 exists, that is just a consequence of removing the "unlisted" visibility option, while it is a completely valid approach.
It is still supported on the web client, it is supported on all other mobile clients, why is it not supported here?
Rather confusing that this useful post option is missing from the iOS client (for no apparent reason?) when it is present on the web client.
@MainasuK
related #231 But that toolbar is omitting unlist on purpose.
What was the purpose?
This is critical to me as I don't like the attention on public, but still want people to organically discover and join conversations where I am involved.
Please enable the unlisted toot. It is a important method of posting when you want to be more public but don’t want to pollute the local timeline.
This is useful for doing threads on Mastodon as you can make the first post public and then replies can be unlisted to keep the timeline less polluted.
It's worse than it even seems: if your actual account is set to default to post Unlisted, the iOS app completely ignores it. This is terrible behavior to have been allowed into a released app. No app for Mastodon should override a user's expressly set settings.
It looks like the code for unlisted is present but just commented out… can it be reinstated?
Yes please. Same question is being raised on the android repo. A strange choice to remove a feature that is still available on the web and in other third-party apps. https://github.com/mastodon/mastodon-android/pull/103
This is useful for doing threads on Mastodon as you can make the first post public and then replies can be unlisted to keep the timeline less polluted.
I also read that this was the preferred practice.
Wanting to be a polite user, I was confused this option was missing here, but present on the web and the other apps I’ve just checked.
As an alternative, I tried setting the post to followers only (I assume people will still see the replies to the original post), but this prevents reposting.
Just saw new people replying on FediTips confused by the lack of unlisted option. It would make sense to restore this option, especially as they see existing users advising them to use this option when posting replies.
It seems that feature parity with the web UX, including (re-)adding missing features such as unlisted posting, has pretty unanimous support in the community, except for @mastodon's UX designer. Is there a reason why design direction hasn't been adjusted?
See also: mastodon/mastodon-android#37, mastodon/mastodon-android#103
This is now essential in light of https://github.com/mastodon/mastodon/pull/26344, which will make all public posts from "discoverable" accounts searchable.
Seriously this is still an issue more than 2 years later? Why? It's clear unlisted posts aren't going away any time soon, why not add them back into the app. The way it is currently is just not good since any replies to posts appear in the timeline as public and not unlisted as replies should.
