PandaPi icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
PandaPi copied to clipboard

PID autotune does not work

Open LeonKnook opened this issue 5 years ago • 11 comments

Today I updated everything possible in de marlin files to make PID autotune work. It does not heat up at all. Over here a zip file with my marlin version so far, maybe I overlooked something?

pandapi.zip

LeonKnook avatar Feb 19 '20 08:02 LeonKnook

hello, V1.0 board needs to update new MCU firmware for PID autotune, https://github.com/markniu/PandaPi/tree/master/firmware https://github.com/markniu/PandaPi/wiki/How-to-flash-MCU-firmware

markniu avatar Feb 20 '20 14:02 markniu

Purchased the ST-Link USB module and uploaded the new firmware. I confirm that the PID autotune works now. In my case the temperature is unfortunately 5 degrees to low.

LeonKnook avatar Feb 29 '20 15:02 LeonKnook

did you update the latest firmware and marlin code that I had updated the yesterday? how about the default Value of PID?or try to ''M303 C10 S210 '' instead of "M303 S210"

markniu avatar Feb 29 '20 15:02 markniu

I refreshed the 3 marlin files you uploaded yesterday and the latest firmware I already had. image image These are the results image

LeonKnook avatar Feb 29 '20 17:02 LeonKnook

And then I printed something image Still around 5 degrees to cold. Can you provide the standard pid settings

LeonKnook avatar Feb 29 '20 18:02 LeonKnook

it seems that the RPI print out wrong PID , it print out some non text words,you can do the autotune one more time. I am testing and debug. set the PID default : M301 P25 I2.4 D66.9 M500

markniu avatar Feb 29 '20 20:02 markniu

The PID default give bad results. image

LeonKnook avatar Mar 01 '20 10:03 LeonKnook

sorry for that bad temperature. so I do more test and fixed it today,but need more test,if you have time you can try to update this new firmware and marlin . following is my test results. image the PID value: P25.00 I2.40 D66.90

markniu avatar Mar 01 '20 15:03 markniu

temperature.h replaced and latest hex file geupload. image

image

LeonKnook avatar Mar 01 '20 20:03 LeonKnook

the I0.002 is too low, try I1, or increase P and D value. when the autotune failed, try again.did it failed everytime?

markniu avatar Mar 03 '20 14:03 markniu

I find that the bed temperature on you board are not stable, because of the noise of the hardware or connect line,so I fixed it with the software,you can update the new firmware. 图片

markniu avatar Mar 14 '20 10:03 markniu