pianoplayer icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
pianoplayer copied to clipboard

Improvement suggestion: Repeats should use same fingers?

Open AmitMY opened this issue 4 years ago • 1 comments

I downloaded this piece as MusicXML https://musescore.com/user/3273631/scores/1012936

And ran pianoplayer on size XXS.

On the second page there are: image

and image

shouldn't it be a really strict rule that if a chord repeats N times (1,2,3...N-1,N) than at the very least 2,3,...N-2,N-1 should use the same fingering?

Bonus question! if you have the time, can you explain why this behavior happened?

AmitMY avatar Apr 06 '20 18:04 AmitMY

Hi Amit, sorry for getting back to late so late .. I don't have a good answer for that and I couldn't download the file to check. Maybe with the latest release it's gone? Anyway I think chords are to be rethought see #33

marcomusy avatar Jan 24 '21 23:01 marcomusy