tiled icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
tiled copied to clipboard

Flag/Mode to be able to draw with "no tile"

Open greggman opened this issue 10 years ago • 4 comments

It would great if there was a mode (preference setting?) where drawing with "no tile" was supported. There's 2 use cases.

  1. You want to move some large area.

    You've got this:

+-----------+
|  A        |
|GBCD EF    |
+-----------+

And you want to move the ABCD area over one to the right

+----------+
|   A      |
|GBBCDEF   |
+----------+

So you select that area, copy and then stamp but you get this

+----------+
|  AA      |
|GBBCDEF   |
+----------+

Because the "no tile" to the left of the A doesn't erase the old A. Cutting instead of copying doesn't help either because that would mean I'd have to manually put in a B. 2. I want to erase a large non-rectangular area

To do this now I either have to use the 1x1 eraser. Or I have to go around selecting rectangles and cutting them. I'd prefer to just be able to "paint/draw" with "no tile". Then when I'm working I have less keys and modes to remember. I just right click a tile, draw with it, if I want to erase I right click a no tile area, now my brush is "no tile" and I draw and it effectively erases. If I right click and select a larger rectangle of "no tile" I can erase larger areas quicker.

Personally I'd likely always be in this mode. I've almost never needed to select a rectangle of tiles and have the no-tiles not erase tiles that are already there. (case #1). I almost always have to go back and clean up the areas the no-tiles in my stamp of tiles didn't erase.

Does this sound like a useful mode?

greggman avatar Oct 30 '14 22:10 greggman

I endorse the suggestion above! Also, it would be good to have an outline around the brush (or an option for one) for when you pick up a rectangle of no-tiles to draw with, so you can see how big your selection/brush is.

JohnnyWasabi avatar Oct 30 '14 22:10 JohnnyWasabi

Actually, simple shading on the no-tile brush tiles, as it does no for non-blank tile brushes would work fine.

JohnnyWasabi avatar Oct 30 '14 22:10 JohnnyWasabi

Being able to right-click sample an empty tile and erase with it instead of having to switch tools would be a great improvement to staying in the flow. It would also be consistent with how when using the Terrain Brush, you can right-click to select the empty terrain and paint with it.

Being able to stamp empty tiles as part of a larger stamp would also be great, I definitely support such a mode. However, I don't think moving tiles already in the map is a great example of a use case, since you can already cut+paste instead of copy+paste, and since it's something better done by a dedicated tool anyway. This would be useful when stamping details in general.

eishiya avatar Jan 02 '22 19:01 eishiya

+1 from me. Would make my life a LOT easier.

glennbroadway avatar Mar 25 '24 14:03 glennbroadway