robosat icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
robosat copied to clipboard

poor prediction in satellite images

Open jaigsingla opened this issue 3 years ago • 4 comments

Hi All,

I am able to get 0.83 of IOU using the Tanzania dataset using your code and able to generate vector files after predictions.
Now, I have a 50cm VHR image over an urban area and corresponding building shape files in geojson format. I applied the same techniques as in the Tanzania dataset and trained the model with an IOU of .67 But, generated segmentation probabilities do not look good, what can be the reason ? I have used batch_size of 16, image_size of 512, lr= 0.00005 and loss function of Lovasz. I will be happy to hear from you.

regards, Jai

jaigsingla avatar Jun 07 '21 09:06 jaigsingla

Can be anything from

  • not enough data
  • poor optimizer settings (lr too low?)
  • not trained for long enough
  • trained for too long
  • ..

By now this project is outdated, unmaintained, and no longer state of the art, too.

On June 7, 2021 9:07:17 AM UTC, jaigsingla @.***> wrote:

Hi All,

I am able to get 0.83 of IOU using the Tanzania dataset using your code and able to generate vector files after predictions.
Now, I have a 50cm VHR image over an urban area and corresponding building shape files in geojson format. I applied the same techniques as in the Tanzania dataset and trained the model with an IOU of .67 But, generated segmentation probabilities do not look good, what can be the reason ? I have used batch_size of 16, image_size of 512, lr= 0.00005 and loss function of Lovasz. I will be happy to hear from you.

regards, Jai

daniel-j-h avatar Jun 18 '21 12:06 daniel-j-h

Hi Daniel,

You are right it may be anything. Can you guide me through? It will be preety useful. In case you have commercial software, pls let me know.

On Fri, 18 Jun 2021, 18:21 Daniel J. H., @.***> wrote:

Can be anything from

  • not enough data
  • poor optimizer settings (lr too low?)
  • not trained for long enough
  • trained for too long
  • ..

By now this project is outdated, unmaintained, and no longer state of the art, too.

On June 7, 2021 9:07:17 AM UTC, jaigsingla @.***> wrote:

Hi All,

I am able to get 0.83 of IOU using the Tanzania dataset using your code and able to generate vector files after predictions. Now, I have a 50cm VHR image over an urban area and corresponding building shape files in geojson format. I applied the same techniques as in the Tanzania dataset and trained the model with an IOU of .67 But, generated segmentation probabilities do not look good, what can be the reason ? I have used batch_size of 16, image_size of 512, lr= 0.00005 and loss function of Lovasz. I will be happy to hear from you.

regards, Jai

— You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/mapbox/robosat/issues/219#issuecomment-864015048, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AGFXXGFB73D353FUHISBII3TTM6M7ANCNFSM46HGVQ4Q .

jaigsingla avatar Jun 18 '21 13:06 jaigsingla

Hi All,

I am able to get 0.83 of IOU using the Tanzania dataset using your code and able to generate vector files after predictions. Now, I have a 50cm VHR image over an urban area and corresponding building shape files in geojson format. I applied the same techniques as in the Tanzania dataset and trained the model with an IOU of .67 But, generated segmentation probabilities do not look good, what can be the reason ? I have used batch_size of 16, image_size of 512, lr= 0.00005 and loss function of Lovasz. I will be happy to hear from you.

regards, Jai

Hello! on which OS have you performed this project?

manapshymyr-OB avatar Jun 28 '21 07:06 manapshymyr-OB

Can be anything from - not enough data - poor optimizer settings (lr too low?) - not trained for long enough - trained for too long - .. By now this project is outdated, unmaintained, and no longer state of the art, too. On June 7, 2021 9:07:17 AM UTC, jaigsingla @.***> wrote: Hi All, I am able to get 0.83 of IOU using the Tanzania dataset using your code and able to generate vector files after predictions. Now, I have a 50cm VHR image over an urban area and corresponding building shape files in geojson format. I applied the same techniques as in the Tanzania dataset and trained the model with an IOU of .67 But, generated segmentation probabilities do not look good, what can be the reason ? I have used batch_size of 16, image_size of 512, lr= 0.00005 and loss function of Lovasz. I will be happy to hear from you. regards, Jai

Hello! Is it possible to run on OS Windows without Docker?

manapshymyr-OB avatar Jun 28 '21 07:06 manapshymyr-OB