google-webfonts-helper icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
google-webfonts-helper copied to clipboard

ttf in Legacy, but no woff

Open Vallek opened this issue 7 months ago • 4 comments

Hi! I noticed that there is ttf fonts in Legacy Support but no woff. And woff is present in Historic Support. Shouldn't it be the other way around? Since ttf is older then woff?

Vallek avatar Nov 26 '23 11:11 Vallek

For background see https://github.com/majodev/google-webfonts-helper/issues/162#issuecomment-1547693525

majodev avatar Nov 26 '23 19:11 majodev

That's a strange reasoning imo)

  1. Yes ttf has more support percentage obviously cause it's older) That's a reason to put in in Historic not Legacy
  2. Not sure I understand compression argument as woff also uses the same source structure. woff2 just has different and better compression.
  3. Also as far as I know up until recently the standard legacy option was woff+woff2 and before that all three. I never saw anyone uses woff2+ttf without woff.

Anyway thanks for this tool!

Vallek avatar Nov 27 '23 09:11 Vallek

@Vallek Roughly six months later, has anything changed with your rationale above? (I'm just a person on the internet trying to help out this project; I don't have any particular experience with font formats.)

xpe avatar May 06 '24 11:05 xpe

@xpe Hi! Nothing changed as far as I know. But I guess the difference between woff and ttf is not that important. The support is pretty similar. woff2+ttf seems wider so i guess it makes sense. It just looked weird to me cause woff2+woff seems more standard. In the end of the day everyone can manually choose what they want)

Also I'm not font expert either and absolutely could be unaware of something else)

Vallek avatar May 06 '24 15:05 Vallek