mRemoteNG icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
mRemoteNG copied to clipboard

Alt Tab on Windows 10

Open cusco opened this issue 7 years ago • 41 comments

Operating system Windows 10 Pro x64
mRemoteNG version 1.75 hotfix 1 (2017-03-06)

Hello all. I've searched on the internet and I find many people reporting this issue. On foruns and Jira, but I didn't find the issue here. Also reports I found are old.

Basically, when i have mRemoteNG opened with at least a putty session, I can't cycle correctly thorough windows applications with alt tab.

  • Have mRemoteNG focused
  • Alt + Tab to another App -> stays on mRemoteNG (is it focusing putty?)
  • Alt + Tab again to another App -> stays on mRemoteNG (is it focusing back mRemoteNG ?)
  • Alt + Tab again (third time) to another App -> changes to the next app (say, browser)
  • Alt + Tab + Tab + Tab to yet another App -> changes to the 3rd App (say, skype)
  • Alt + Tab should go back to mRemoteNG but no. mRemoteNG stays in 3rd place

Any window/app that I focus to, will then be always before mRemoteNG. Unless I click on the putty window inside mRemoteNG then I go back to the beginning.

Is there a way to fix this annoying issue? Don't take me wrong, I enjoy mRemoteNG and have been using it for the past 3 years or so, but this is really annoying!

cusco avatar Apr 20 '17 14:04 cusco

Thanks for adding your report here. Yea, there are a number of very annoying focus-related issues in the application. I don't believe we have these issues scheduled yet, but they are on our mind.

sparerd avatar Apr 20 '17 14:04 sparerd

@cusco Please upvote / track this problem via #290

kmscode avatar Apr 20 '17 18:04 kmscode

I found out that check on the option"Allow only a single instance" would surprisingly fix this issue!

Tools->Options->Startup/Exit->Allos only a single instance of application

wakinowen avatar Jan 05 '18 07:01 wakinowen

Yes, it indeed works !! Thanks @wakinowen

charannaik avatar Jan 08 '18 04:01 charannaik

Worked for me too @wakinowen

Tinostarn avatar Mar 08 '18 17:03 Tinostarn

@wakinowen, this works for me! :)

fred070 avatar May 08 '18 08:05 fred070

It works

fpelaezt avatar May 25 '18 15:05 fpelaezt

@wakinowen it does not seem to work for me!

Activate the option, exit remote-ng, open remote-ng and 2 putty sessions. Same issue. Alt tab will not cycle correctly :(

cusco avatar May 28 '18 16:05 cusco

The problem still exist and I agree with @cusco, workaround doesn't work

romangit avatar Jul 05 '18 07:07 romangit

the workaround by @wakinowen doesn't resolve the issue in my setup - win10 1.75.7012.16814

Idanatcox avatar Oct 02 '18 14:10 Idanatcox

Is there any way to disable Alt+Tab so that it no longer cycles through remote windows but only local windows. This is how RoyalTS works: you use Alt+PgUp/Down to cycle through remote windows.

cawoodm avatar May 06 '19 08:05 cawoodm

it works on Win 10 64 bit..
===UPDATE=== Only works at first time, after you exit the app and open again the problem happened again, you need to recheck and check again the "Allow only a single instance of application"

aswzen avatar Jul 08 '19 05:07 aswzen

@wakinowen it does not seem to work for me!

Activate the option, exit remote-ng, open remote-ng and 2 putty sessions. Same issue. Alt tab will not cycle correctly :(

in putty configuration, Window-->behaviour , check on "Ensure window is always on top" it works for me.

howdoyoudoooo avatar Jul 20 '19 03:07 howdoyoudoooo

For quick fix, i just attach the remoteNg app to cmder app image ..and the alt+tab issue gone

update: 10 oct.. its not working anymore :(

aswzen avatar Aug 15 '19 04:08 aswzen

For quick fix, i just attach the remoteNg app to cmder app image ..and the alt+tab issue gone

Didn't try it yet, nor do I know cmder, but I can imagine it works. I will probably tap into this myself

cusco avatar Aug 17 '19 20:08 cusco

Unfortunately with cmder it does not work for me.

When Alt-Tabing between writing on Puttyng (inside mremoteng) and notepad the first alt-tab goes back to cmder instead of notepad. Only the second alt-tab switches to notepad.

pedroeloy avatar Oct 10 '19 12:10 pedroeloy

Weird ALT-TAB behavior indeed.

Looks like the row with apps, which is shown after pressing ALT-TAB, isn't updated correctly after selecting mRemoteNG. The program is selected okay, the row afterwards isn't updated: mRemoteNG stays in its previous position (2nd, 3rd, whatever). The focus in the row (white border) is correct on the previous app but it is still in front.

After selecting mRemote for the 2nd time the row get updated correctly and mRemoteNG shows up in front and the previous app, with focus, on the second place.

But then the focus inside your connection (putty) is lost...

But how can an application mess up this ALT-TABing? Isn't that an OS thing.

loxiagit avatar Nov 01 '19 11:11 loxiagit

I'm now in the situation that Alt+Tab works remotely on some servers and Alt+PgUp works on others. This is crazy.

cawoodm avatar Nov 01 '19 18:11 cawoodm

@loxiagit

I'm guessing this weird behaviour is related to the fact that mremoteng is embedding another window/application? (Putty) into itself so focus gets messes up with that.

If you only need to ALT+TAB between a focused Putty Tab and just 1 external application It kind of works but has soon has you change focus to something else it becomes unusable again.

pedroeloy avatar Nov 02 '19 09:11 pedroeloy

This issue has been reported since 6 more years ago and having no actual update fix since, the only work around for me in windows 10 was by putting mRemoteNG application to the first order in bottom taskbar, then when i want to switch to mRemoteNG i just press Win + 1 Good luck

aswzen avatar Nov 12 '19 04:11 aswzen

Is this still not fixed in April 2020? It is such an annoying issue that I'm sure other people than me are considering switching to alternatives. Other than this issue mRemoteNG is fantastic.

jogyo avatar Apr 17 '20 13:04 jogyo

Still happening, and after applying this workaround it happens SOMETIMES.
Awfully weird and inconsistent

lukecamilo avatar Apr 29 '20 22:04 lukecamilo

This is still happening for me. Version 1.76.20.24615

mbuc avatar Jun 27 '20 04:06 mbuc

  1. Very annoying. Is there any other app, that doesn't have this issue? I always have to use my mouse just to switch back to mRemoteNG from my PHPstom or ant other window.
  2. ALSO if I click on text region of mRemoteNG, the cursor itself sets to cli string, and I even can type something, WHILE WINDOW ITSELF IS NOT FOCUSED. This is sooo strange behaviour...

konstantin83 avatar Oct 19 '20 13:10 konstantin83

How is this still a thing so many years later ? It's an otherwise excellent application, but this is extremely annoying behaviour.

therightstuff avatar Dec 22 '21 09:12 therightstuff

I have 1.76.20 version with latest till now, but still not working. Please fix this issue, else I had to use windows remote desktop to skip that I am using this app.

Updating my old commit: to reply how it is working. Just you need to go to "Config" and under config find the "Redirect" under that select "Key Combination" as Yes. You are done and working properly. Attaching the image which is also showing the description how to send Alt+TAB to remote. image

royujjal avatar Dec 24 '21 06:12 royujjal

(Tested) You can try this way:

  • in mRemoteNG, menu Tools->Options->Startup/Exit->Allow only a single instance of application... -> restart mRemoteNG
  • in cmder -> menu -> Attach to -> select mRemoteNG

in attach mode, some menu to mRemoteNG is not display properly, also lagging when resize cmder windows if current tab is mRemoteNG.

NothingCtrl avatar Dec 24 '21 06:12 NothingCtrl

Is this still not fixed in April 2020? It is such an annoying issue that I'm sure other people than me are considering switching to alternatives. Other than this issue mRemoteNG is fantastic.

This is a killer for me as well. It hurts my productivity and is annoying on top, which makes me leave this app for now.

Kongolan avatar Dec 27 '21 01:12 Kongolan

@Kongolan as I said I have tested with nRemoteNG only and it is working for me with the above settings (commented above) I have made. So, please use this app and pleasure to use it.

royujjal avatar Dec 27 '21 06:12 royujjal

@Kongolan as I said I have tested with nRemoteNG only and it is working for me with the above settings (commented above) I have made. So, please use this app and pleasure to use it.

Ok Update, the redirect thing is there, changed to yes and then still unable to focus after unfocusing the remoteNG ssh

image

aswzen avatar Dec 29 '21 04:12 aswzen

@aswzen it's not in the connection global settings - please check my comment. It is in the 'Config' that will be shown only when you select a remote connection. I have selected the remote erased as RED color - see the image. image

Also, you can do it globally which will be applied only for new connections. So, you can apply globally I have edited your image check and apply the same on those properties for 'Redirect->Inherit Key Combination=yes'. Once you clink on any connection marked as green color tick in config it will show in cross with color RED. image

royujjal avatar Dec 29 '21 13:12 royujjal