scale icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
scale copied to clipboard

[Feature Request] Is it possible to push/pull the function to an OCI compatible registry?

Open heww opened this issue 1 year ago • 2 comments

Acceptance Criteria

  • scale fn oci-push exists
    • Before pushing, Scale transforms the Scale Function and Signature into an OCI
    • The OCI is pushed to the destination registry
  • scale fn oci-pull exists
    • The OCI is pulled from the source registry
    • After pulling, Scale transforms the OCI back to a regular Scale Function and Signature

Questions

  • ~How could we pass function params and get the appropriate output from the registry?~
    • The OCI just describes a root file system and doesn't care about the file contents.
    • We could include both a signature and a function in a .tar.gz file that gets pushed to the registry.
  • ~Would the OCI include the runner?~
    • Nope, we'd just build an unpacking step.

heww avatar Mar 15 '23 01:03 heww

The more we talk about this internally, the more it seems like that could make sense.

There are downsides to this approach (namely that we can't modify/transform your code at the registry layer, all modifications have to happen locally before you push to the registry).

At the same time, we gain access to the myriad of OCI-compliant registries.

It's a nuanced issue, and I think the best thing to do is wait until the Signatures V1 release (which is coming soon, join our discord!) and then once we have enough users of that we can have a proper community meeting to make a decision on this.

ShivanshVij avatar Mar 23 '23 23:03 ShivanshVij

+1 to wanting OCI-compatible registry support. It would allow to easier adoption in a corporate setting. I would even prefer to run modifications locally.

Handfish avatar Jan 05 '24 15:01 Handfish

This will likely be part of future plans, but at this time is out of our current scope. However, we are definitely open to community contributions for this feature :)

dphilla avatar Aug 22 '24 17:08 dphilla