OpenBVE icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
OpenBVE copied to clipboard

[Bug] Brake handles with holding brake don't play handle sounds around the Hold notch

Open hotdamndel opened this issue 1 year ago • 2 comments

Description

No handle sound when moving brake handle from Hold.

Reproduction

Happens on any train with handle sounds.

Related information

Release 1.9.2.2

hotdamndel avatar Nov 13 '23 18:11 hotdamndel

Hmm....

This might possibly have been intentional; I'll have to check with regards to what BVE4 does before making any immediate decisions as to whether it's actually a bug. Technically speaking the hold brake is an additional device, and often wouldn't be integrated with the main handle itself.

Tempted to add a new sound played when the handle is moved to / from HLD, similar to the EMG one.

leezer3 avatar Nov 13 '23 18:11 leezer3

When it's a single notch in braking range (in BVE4 implementation, its irl counterpart is always automatic hold brake with that one notch), it does appear on brake or combined handle and normally isn't mechanically different so sound is the same (this is ofc Japanese practice, covering every possible combo worldwide needs a much more flexible train config system overall). Possibly having much more customization for notch sounds is a good idea btw (like, an individual sound for when notch i is selected)

hotdamndel avatar Nov 13 '23 19:11 hotdamndel