trifecta icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
trifecta copied to clipboard

Native consumer groups support in v0.22 RC's

Open plachor opened this issue 7 years ago • 4 comments

Hi I could not force native consumer groups support in RC8 and RC6 (version 0.22):

  • trifecta-ui-0.22.0rc8b-0.10.1.0.zip
  • trifecta-ui-0.22.0rc6h-0.10.1.0.zip

After some investigation of source code it seems you drop support of Kafka native groups and check only for Zookeeper groups.

In version RC6 there was API exposing /api/consumers and /api/consumers/lite the lite version was working only with zookeeper groups and this one was used by UI. Although /api/consumers was not used was working if called manually.

As for version RC8 there seems to be only support for Zookeeper groups.

Will you release new version with native Kafka groups support ?

Some links for investigation:

  • https://github.com/ldaniels528/trifecta/blob/109905188b4f774e0adc177b25aadc70681299c5/app-play/app/com/github/ldaniels528/trifecta/ui/controllers/KafkaPlayRestFacade.scala#L207-L211
  • https://github.com/ldaniels528/trifecta/blob/master/app-play/app/com/github/ldaniels528/trifecta/ui/controllers/KafkaPlayRestFacade.scala#L234-L236
  • https://github.com/ldaniels528/trifecta/blob/109905188b4f774e0adc177b25aadc70681299c5/src/main/scala/com/github/ldaniels528/trifecta/io/kafka/KafkaZkUtils.scala#L111-L113

Seems like you left the support of Kafka native groupst in your console client:

  • https://github.com/ldaniels528/trifecta/blob/master/app-cli/src/main/scala/com/github/ldaniels528/trifecta/modules/kafka/KafkaCliFacade.scala#L100-L140

Any chance for an estimate when if at all it can be expected :) ?

plachor avatar Jun 28 '17 14:06 plachor

I've been planning to revisit consumer groups and overhaul it to support many different configurations, but I just haven't had any time lately to do so. The short answer is I plan to work on this soon, but there's currently no ETA.

ldaniels528 avatar Jun 29 '17 02:06 ldaniels528

Thnx for quick response :)

plachor avatar Jun 29 '17 04:06 plachor

+1 this breaks in our case too. Hoping for a fix soon.

gamefundas avatar Sep 25 '17 13:09 gamefundas

Any update on this?

ebclark2 avatar Aug 29 '18 16:08 ebclark2