hotcrp icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
hotcrp copied to clipboard

Deleting PC Member's Review Unassigns the PC Member

Open PhilippWoelfel opened this issue 4 years ago • 2 comments

Suppose a PC member is assigned to a paper and has written a review. Admin then deletes the review of the PC member. As a result, the PC member is not assigned to the paper anymore. This is unexpected and can easily be overlooked by a PC chair.

PhilippWoelfel avatar Mar 13 '22 13:03 PhilippWoelfel

Can you say more about why this is unexpected? This seems totally expected.

kohler avatar Feb 16 '23 19:02 kohler

It's been awhile, so hopefully I remember correctly. There is a dependency in one direction: Assignment of a PC member to a paper is necessary for the PC member to submit a review. But not vice versa. So why should removing the review also remove the PC member from that paper?

PhilippWoelfel avatar Feb 16 '23 21:02 PhilippWoelfel