[Question] 2 Configuration questions/problems

[nlafleur]

Ask your questions I have 2 questions about the elkjs configuration:

1. The ordering should be closer to the "expected behavior screenshot" (perferably a (top-left to bottom right) ordering by node ID (added red number in "expected behaviour screenshot" at the nodes))
2. The current behavior draws the edges across the nodes, would be nice if this can be prevented. I've tried setting the "Edge routing" to SPLINES:

  "elk.edgeRouting": "SPLINES",
  "elk.layered.edgeRouting.splines.mode": "CONSERVATIVE",

but this doesn't give the expected result:

I am using "React-Flow" with the "Elk js" algorithm. This is my configuration:

const elkOptions = {
  "elk.algorithm": "layered",
  "elk.hierarchyHandling": "INCLUDE_CHILDREN",

  "elk.spacing.commentComment": 0,
  "elk.spacing.commentNode": 0,
  "elk.spacing.componentComponent": 0,
  "elk.spacing.edgeLabel": 0,
  "elk.spacing.edgeNode": 0,
  "elk.spacing.edgeEdge": 0,
  "elk.spacing.labelPortHorizontal": 0,
  "elk.spacing.labelNode": 0,
  "elk.spacing.labelLabel": 0,
  "elk.spacing.nodeSelfLoop": 0,
  "elk.spacing.nodeNode": 50, // verticale spacing tussen node
  "elk.spacing.portPort": 0,

  "elk.layered.compaction.connectedComponents": false,
  "elk.layered.wrapping.additionalEdgeSpacing": 0,
  "elk.layered.wrapping.multiEdge.improveCuts": true,
  "elk.layered.wrapping.multiEdge.improveWrappedEdges": true,
  "elk.layered.spacing.edgeEdgeBetweenLayers": 0,
  "elk.layered.spacing.edgeNodeBetweenLayers": 0,
  "elk.layered.spacing.nodeNodeBetweenLayers": 100, // horizontale spacing tussen nodes
}

Expected behavior This was the concept drawing of the nodes: Please ignore the text outside the "nodes"

Screenshots This is the current (initial) behavior based on the config above:

ELK Version "elkjs": "0.9.3" "reactflow": "11.11.4"

[soerendomroes]

You might want to take a look at this blogpost if you want to constrain the ordering of nodes.

The edge node overlaps are a problem of reactflow. Typically, this happens since the rendering of the node is bigger than the layout node ELK receives.

I would also ask you to replicate your issue in elk-live (which is currently down so maybe do that later). This way you could try out different options and see how they work together using only ELK.

[Eddykasp]

If elk-live is down you can also run it yourself using docker docker run ghcr.io/kieler/elk-live:master. The links to graphs it exports will work for any hosted elk-live.

https://github.com/kieler/elk-live/pkgs/container/elk-live