etherpad-lite icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
etherpad-lite copied to clipboard

Pad settings don't persist past a browser refresh

Open paulproteus opened this issue 7 years ago • 5 comments

Steps to reproduce:

  • Create a new Sandstorm Etherpad grain

  • Change the authorship sidebar to not appear for this grain

  • Reload the page

Expected results:

  • Authorship sidebar continues to not appear for this grain

Actual results:

  • That setting is reset to its default of "Yes", show the authorship sidebar

Video of steps to reproduce:

out

paulproteus avatar Nov 18 '16 21:11 paulproteus

Sortof-dupe of #17? (I imagine you'd ideally like these settings to persist across all pads.)

kentonv avatar Nov 19 '16 01:11 kentonv

I am OK with them not persisting across all pads, since grains are isolated etc. But if I set a setting on a particular grain, I would definitely like it to be set for that one grain!

paulproteus avatar Nov 19 '16 08:11 paulproteus

To clarify - I don't need it to persist across all pads. Upon reflection, I actively don't want it to persist across all pads, at least for this setting. Some pads of mine are multi-author and some are single-author.

paulproteus avatar Nov 29 '16 22:11 paulproteus

Copy of detail we sent in to Sandstorm:

We don't use "Authorship colours" "Line numbers" or "Spell check." Frankly it's important to economize on both JS events and server hits, so turning these off makes both typing and viewing much more amenable. However, these aren't saved as cookies, so each time the product must reload or we otherwise come back to a document, it resets these and we must remember to turn them off. It falls under "annoyance" category but the product needs reloading several times a day. After dozens of times unchecking checkboxes every week, the time invested adds up.

pzelchenko avatar Dec 05 '16 06:12 pzelchenko

@pzelchenko FWIW turning off those features won't have any effect on network traffic; they're purely cosmetic. Also in recent updates we vastly improved the authorship colors to be less annoying, so I'd suggest trying them again after you update.

That said, I agree that these options should be sticky.

kentonv avatar Dec 13 '16 05:12 kentonv