BR24radar_pi
BR24radar_pi copied to clipboard
Enhance guard zone alarms to have multiple levels
Marcus writes:
We can't make alarms that produce anything that needs to be confirmed or reset to keep normal operation of a navigation system. Ever. For any reason. Many professional manufacturers have managed to make their alarms unusable and dangerous this way, just look at Raymarines AIS alarms on the E-series. Useless.
An alarm should be visible but not intrusive. There is no way to know that this alarm is the most important thing for the mariner in that exact time.
If I remember correctly, disruptive alarms are not allowed in the ECDIS standard, and for a good reason.
If we see this as purely a "I am on a crossing without a boat in sight and need to take a nap" kind of alarm, OK, I can turn it off and never use it. But that would be a pity because it could be very useful in other situations as well.
Ideally, there could be 3 levels to select from
- Off
- Normal
- Audible
- Intrusive
Normal alarm should be visual only, for example the target becomes red and/or flashes, and/or guard zone flashes. Corresponding to the ECDIS standard for dangerous AIS targets. Audible should be like normal but with a single sound when this state occurs Intrusive should be like we discuss now, something you cant get to shut up without confirming....