tsMuxer icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
tsMuxer copied to clipboard

Question about extracting TrueHD audio

Open efraim-il opened this issue 5 years ago • 4 comments

Hi,

I noticed a note the main page: "please note TrueHD must have the AC3 core intact" Can you please explain what it means? How can I know if the TrueHD track on a Bluray has AC3 core? Thank you

efraim-il avatar Oct 31 '20 15:10 efraim-il

Hi @efraim-il , all Blu-rays have interleaved AC-3/TrueHD frames -pure TrueHD (without ac3 frames) is not compatible with Blu-ray. So when you extract the TrueHD track from a Blu-ray with tsMuxer, it always has interleaved AC-3 frames.

jcdr428 avatar Oct 31 '20 17:10 jcdr428

Also while ac3 is not used to decode TrueHD, like in DTS MA, it is used to decode EAC3, if it is present.

"E-AC3 on Blu-ray is not a full E-AC3 stream. It uses an ordinary 5.1 AC3 stream and a second E-AC3 extension stream that contains 4 channels which are supposed to replace the back channel from the AC3 5.1, and add two more channel for a 7.1 mix."

ValZapod avatar May 31 '21 11:05 ValZapod

@jcdr428, @ValZapod should we look at updating the documentation? It seems like we get questions similar to this quite a bit.

justdan96 avatar Jun 15 '21 13:06 justdan96

should we look at updating the documentation

It is on wikipedia, LOL. I wrote it there, people who really wanted to know would have just visited it. BTW, what do you know about gap processing of truehd on segment boundaries? See this http://rationalqm.us/board/viewtopic.php?f=16&t=793&p=11193&hilit=Tsmuxer#p11193critics:

ValZapod avatar Jun 15 '21 13:06 ValZapod