frontends-team-compass icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
frontends-team-compass copied to clipboard

JupyterLab Extension Repo Naming Convention

Open tgeorgeux opened this issue 5 years ago • 5 comments

In the Jupyterlab org we have 22 extensions name jupyterlab-* and 12 extensions with no "jupyterlab-" in the name, can we make a convention that we name all the extensions the same?

I personally vote for not using "jupyterlab-" in the name of repos that are already in the jupyterlab org. So "jupyterlab-commenting" would become "commenting" etc.

tgeorgeux avatar Dec 04 '19 15:12 tgeorgeux

I strongly support and prefer removing the jupyterlab- from all repositories that are already in github.com/jupyterlab/______________

afshin avatar Dec 04 '19 16:12 afshin

A downside of removing a leading "jupyterlab " is that forks on personal accounts will have much more opaque names.

ian-r-rose avatar Dec 04 '19 16:12 ian-r-rose

Forks can be renamed and could add the jupyterlab- part? (although this adds an extra manual step).

jtpio avatar Dec 04 '19 17:12 jtpio

That's a good point, @ian-r-rose, but I think the clarity of a nice URL for the repo is valuable enough to still recommend this convention.

Do you think it's a fatal flaw?

afshin avatar Dec 04 '19 17:12 afshin

I don't think it's a fatal flaw, and as @jtpio points out, it can be renamed after the fact. Overall, I don't think I have a strong opinion on this, but I don't have any problem with the current jupyterlab- names.

ian-r-rose avatar Dec 04 '19 19:12 ian-r-rose