LUNA16-Lung-Nodule-Analysis-2016-Challenge icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
LUNA16-Lung-Nodule-Analysis-2016-Challenge copied to clipboard

Mis-matching Total number of candidates

Open MjdMahasneh opened this issue 4 years ago • 1 comments

Hello,

after evaluating the predictions file (i.e. METU_VISION_FPRED.csv) using the LUNA16 official script (i.e. noduleCADEvaluationLUNA16.py), I get an output (CADAnalysis.txt) like this :

CADAnalysis.txt

CAD Analysis: METU_VISION_FPRED

Candidate detection results: True positives: 1128 False positives: 81706 False negatives: 58 True negatives: 0 Total number of candidates: 87794 Total number of nodules: 1186 Ignored candidates on excluded nodules: 4600 Ignored candidates which were double detections on a nodule: 360 Sensitivity: 0.951096121 Average number of candidates per scan: 98.867117117

From what I understand, the the Total number of candidates should be 754,975 according to https://luna16.grand-challenge.org/Evaluation/

Even though METU_VISION_FPRED.csv has 754,975 candidates!! the CADAnalysis.txt still says Total number of candidates: 87794 !!!!!

Looking forward to hearing back from you. Any help is extremely appreciated.

Many thanks.

Any idea why that happens?? Am I missing something?

MjdMahasneh avatar Jun 12 '20 17:06 MjdMahasneh

Hello,

after evaluating the predictions file (i.e. METU_VISION_FPRED.csv) using the LUNA16 official script (i.e. noduleCADEvaluationLUNA16.py), I get an output (CADAnalysis.txt) like this :

CADAnalysis.txt

CAD Analysis: METU_VISION_FPRED

Candidate detection results: True positives: 1128 False positives: 81706 False negatives: 58 True negatives: 0 Total number of candidates: 87794 Total number of nodules: 1186 Ignored candidates on excluded nodules: 4600 Ignored candidates which were double detections on a nodule: 360 Sensitivity: 0.951096121 Average number of candidates per scan: 98.867117117

From what I understand, the the Total number of candidates should be 754,975 according to https://luna16.grand-challenge.org/Evaluation/

Even though METU_VISION_FPRED.csv has 754,975 candidates!! the CADAnalysis.txt still says Total number of candidates: 87794 !!!!!

Looking forward to hearing back from you. Any help is extremely appreciated.

Many thanks.

Any idea why that happens?? Am I missing something?

hi,thank you for replying detail message,but i don't known how to explain it.

junqiangchen avatar Nov 30 '20 04:11 junqiangchen