Jessica Clarke

Also: projects like GCC are very different to something like sail-riscv. Many of the people reviewing patches on the GCC mailing list are full-time employees paid by their organisation to...

Putting pointer masking inside translateAddr would compose poorly with DDC on CHERI, which should authorise the actual masked virtual address used.

> Thanks for an incredibly quick and thorough review. But, at one point you say there shouldn't be random spaces, but the guidelines said you can add them to align...

At a glance I don't think the extension hooks comments have been properly addressed

> > At a glance I don't think the extension hooks comments have been properly addressed > > Sorry. Do you mean ext_data_get_addr problem? Yes. You give it a register...

> > > > At a glance I don't think the extension hooks comments have been properly addressed > > > > > > > > > Sorry. Do you...

* The commit message is all one giant subject line; please have a proper subject, and line wrap the body * --as-needed, unless I’m missing something, has no effect on...

Linking against what dynamic libraries? You’re creating a static executable. That’s my point; it is only meaningful when dynamic libraries are involved, but -static means they are not, by definition.

Well, your commit message is improperly formatted, but otherwise I don't think so beyond the continued dysfunction of this project.

My understanding is the spec permits the behaviour you believe to be a problem.