joomla-cms [5.2] Usability: One Articles Module to Rule Them All

[5.2] Usability: One Articles Module to Rule Them All

Open pe7er opened this issue 9 months ago • 2 comments

In Joomla 5.2 we would like to have one new “Site Articles” module with parameters to replace all individual Site Article modules in the future:

Articles - Archived
Articles - Categories
Articles - Category
Articles - Latest
Articles - Most Read
Articles - Newsflash
Articles - Related

In Joomla 5.2 we just want to have this module as extra module. From Joomla 6 on, we could consider to stop shipping the old modules with new installations, and automatically convert them to the new module.

The new module should allow multiple category selection using the "fancy select" class.

@webgras compared the functionality of the old Articles modules in a spreadsheet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/13893BpWLdTBL1Wpe3PH3O6G7zQOFE_8oiqMBeh95f6M/edit#gid=0

Apr 30 '24 09:04 pe7er

While I support the idea of a NEW module the idea that there could ever be a migration/conversion would be almost impossible to achieve. You only need to read the JCM etc to see some of the creative ways that these modules have been used with layouts and overrides. Thinking of just a few of my own I cant see anyway that they could be migrated/converted

Apr 30 '24 10:04 brianteeman

I would suggest not to write migration code and it's not really needed, we just don't ship mod_articles_* in the future (maybe directly starting with 5.2) and have a good documentation how the migration could be done manually.

So you don't need to implement all features the old modules have and which maybe doesn't make sense anymore and on the other side you can make new features not having a b/c issue.