MegaCommand_Design icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
MegaCommand_Design copied to clipboard
verified publisher icon jmamma

MIDI send/receive firmware test fail

Open jabarbanel opened this issue 4 years ago • 3 comments

Hi Justin-

I have moved this issue over from the Elektronauts forum. I posted there last week about having issues with the MIDI ins and outs of my MegaCommand build.

Summary - I've been building my MegaCommand as per the instructions on GitHub. Passed the SRAM and button/encoder tests and have now hit a wall at the MIDI out/in firmware tests.

My setup: I have a MOTU MIDI Express XT connected to my PC and Ableton. I’m using the front panel MIDI ports (channel 8) to send/receive. With my Machinedrum connected, I can play sounds from the machinedrum with my keyboard, and when I play a pattern on the machinedrum I see MIDI note info lighting up on the MIDI interface (as well as in Ableton). So I confirmed that the MIDI setup is working as it should.

Here is the latest update on what I have done as far as troubleshooting: I am only working on the MIDI out circuit since it is so simple - but I did confirm the optoisolators are installed correctly for the input circuits.

  1. Confirmed the Arduino is functioning properly. I was able to recreate the MIDI out circuit on a breadboard to confirm my Arduino is working: 96EC5C23-7A7E-4F97-99FB-D1F6E39CBA7A_1_105_c With this setup I ran the MegaCommand MIDI-out test firmware and confirmed note data being received by my MIDI interface. (side note - I was working with an older cheap arduino clone that had the rx1/tx1 pins either mislabeled or miswired, so I bought another clone and confirmed the pins are correct and functional)

  2. Checked continuity between all the points of the MIDI send/receive circuitry on the pcb between from the arduino headers all the way to the MIDI connectors - everything looks good.

  3. Cleaned the PCB with 99% Isopropyl Alcohol

  4. Checked another PCB from my order (I had the minimum of 5 made) by connecting only the MIDI out connections and resistors for TX1 output (see picture) - and WAS able to produce MIDI out notes that I confirmed on my interface: F1571351-25AE-4043-AEE7-2249CFB5D294_1_105_c

  5. Visual inspection of solder joints (looks OK to my untrained eyes)

  6. Used a multimeter to confirm the resistors are 220Ohm - check

I'm really confused about this! I really would appreciate any insight / guidance on how to proceed at this point. Also here are pics of the build so far for reference.

1594B999-8732-49B4-B943-9450BB870183_1_105_c 7903F47C-98D1-4483-9E67-89B09F5AA795_1_105_c

Thanks for your time Justin, I really appreciate it. -Jonathan

jabarbanel avatar Jul 16 '21 21:07 jabarbanel

Jonathan your MIDI jacks are installed on the wrong side of the PCB!! 🙀

jmamma avatar Jul 17 '21 08:07 jmamma

Please see the reference photography.

https://github.com/jmamma/MegaCommand_Design/tree/master/1_0_2/photos

jmamma avatar Jul 17 '21 08:07 jmamma

omg. I wish there was a word for feeling simultaneously elated and mortified at the same time. Elated to have the solution be so simple and obvious. Mortified that I made such a bonehead rookie mistake.

Anyway thanks for the response! I have some fun desoldering work ahead - just ordered a fresh roll of desoldering braid because my solder sucker isn't removing enough to remove these jacks.

I'll post a confirmation once I get these jacks installed properly just to have some closure.

Thanks again Justin. I'll just show myself out...

:flushed:


jabarbanel avatar Jul 17 '21 20:07 jabarbanel