jenkinsci
[JENKINS-56318] GitHub initial push triggers 2 builds from Multibranch pipeline
we have a pipeline setup to build all branches. on an initial push of a branch two builds are kicked off for the branch that is pushed at the same time.
at 12:57 i pushed here's the output from the push log in jenkins
[Tue Feb 26 11:26:11 MST 2019] Push event to branch master in repository commerce/catalog UPDATED event from 10.0.17.214 ⇒ http://ci-m1.body.prod:8080/github-webhook/ with timestamp Tue Feb 26 11:26:05 MST 2019 processed in 0.47 sec
[Wed Feb 27 12:57:21 MST 2019] Received Push event to branch BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79 in repository commerce/catalog CREATED event from 10.0.17.214 ⇒ http://ci-m1.body.prod:8080/github-webhook/ with timestamp Wed Feb 27 12:57:16 MST 2019
12:57:21 Connecting to http://github.body.prod/api/v3 using Jenkins_Github/****** (Github collaborator account for Jenkins)
Examining commerce/catalog
Checking branches...
Getting remote branch BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79...
[Wed Feb 27 12:57:21 MST 2019] Received Push event to branch BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79 in repository commerce/catalog CREATED event from 10.0.17.214 ⇒ http://ci-m1.body.prod:8080/github-webhook/ with timestamp Wed Feb 27 12:57:16 MST 2019
12:57:21 Connecting to http://github.body.prod/api/v3 using Jenkins_Github/****** (Github collaborator account for Jenkins)
Examining commerce/catalog
Checking branches...
Getting remote branch BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79...
Checking branch BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79
‘Jenkinsfile’ found
Met criteria
Checking branch BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79
‘Jenkinsfile’ found
Met criteria
Scheduled build for branch: BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79
1 branches were processed (query completed)
1 branches were processed
Finished examining commerce/catalog
[Wed Feb 27 12:57:23 MST 2019] Push event to branch BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79 in repository commerce/catalog CREATED event from 10.0.17.214 ⇒ http://ci-m1.body.prod:8080/github-webhook/ with timestamp Wed Feb 27 12:57:16 MST 2019 processed in 2.4 sec
Changes detected: BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79 (null → f5190721fcc185d03a1eb7f6e83729a5d4b10135)
Scheduled build for branch: BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79
1 branches were processed (query completed)
1 branches were processed
Finished examining commerce/catalog
[Wed Feb 27 12:57:24 MST 2019] Push event to branch BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79 in repository commerce/catalog CREATED event from 10.0.17.214 ⇒ http://ci-m1.body.prod:8080/github-webhook/ with timestamp Wed Feb 27 12:57:16 MST 2019 processed in 2.5 sec
[Wed Feb 27 13:02:18 MST 2019] Received Push event to branch BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79 in repository commerce/catalog UPDATED event from 10.0.17.214 ⇒ http://ci-m1.body.prod:8080/github-webhook/ with timestamp Wed Feb 27 13:02:13 MST 2019
13:02:18 Connecting to http://github.body.prod/api/v3 using Jenkins_Github/****** (Github collaborator account for Jenkins)
Examining commerce/catalog
two pushes are delivered at the same time and thus two builds are run. The two pushes seem to be 1 from a repo hook and 1 from the org hook.
The repo shows the push
see the webhook to our ci-m1.body.prod server.
at the org level we have another hook
it pushed at 12:57 as well
i'm thinking the two pushes race with each other. the problem is AFAIK it was the github-plugin that setup the two hooks to begin with! so it's causing it's own problems...
wondering if maybe i just have a misconfiguration...but i don't think so.
Originally reported by drdamour, imported from: GitHub initial push triggers 2 builds from Multibranch pipeline
- assignee:
lanwen
- status: Open
- priority: Minor
- component(s): github-plugin
- label(s): github-plugin, jenkins, multi-branch, pipeline, plugin
- resolution: Unresolved
- votes: 0
- watchers: 1
- imported: 2025-12-08
Raw content of original issue
we have a pipeline setup to build all branches. on an initial push of a branch two builds are kicked off for the branch that is pushed at the same time.
at 12:57 i pushed here's the output from the push log in jenkins
[Tue Feb 26 11:26:11 MST 2019] Push event to branch master in repository commerce/catalog UPDATED event from 10.0.17.214 ⇒ http://ci-m1.body.prod:8080/github-webhook/ with timestamp Tue Feb 26 11:26:05 MST 2019 processed in 0.47 sec [Wed Feb 27 12:57:21 MST 2019] Received Push event to branch BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79 in repository commerce/catalog CREATED event from 10.0.17.214 ⇒ http://ci-m1.body.prod:8080/github-webhook/ with timestamp Wed Feb 27 12:57:16 MST 2019 12:57:21 Connecting to http://github.body.prod/api/v3 using Jenkins_Github/****** (Github collaborator account for Jenkins) Examining commerce/catalog Checking branches... Getting remote branch BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79... [Wed Feb 27 12:57:21 MST 2019] Received Push event to branch BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79 in repository commerce/catalog CREATED event from 10.0.17.214 ⇒ http://ci-m1.body.prod:8080/github-webhook/ with timestamp Wed Feb 27 12:57:16 MST 2019 12:57:21 Connecting to http://github.body.prod/api/v3 using Jenkins_Github/****** (Github collaborator account for Jenkins) Examining commerce/catalog Checking branches... Getting remote branch BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79... Checking branch BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79 ‘Jenkinsfile’ found Met criteria Checking branch BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79 ‘Jenkinsfile’ found Met criteria Scheduled build for branch: BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79 1 branches were processed (query completed) 1 branches were processed Finished examining commerce/catalog [Wed Feb 27 12:57:23 MST 2019] Push event to branch BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79 in repository commerce/catalog CREATED event from 10.0.17.214 ⇒ http://ci-m1.body.prod:8080/github-webhook/ with timestamp Wed Feb 27 12:57:16 MST 2019 processed in 2.4 sec Changes detected: BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79 (null → f5190721fcc185d03a1eb7f6e83729a5d4b10135) Scheduled build for branch: BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79 1 branches were processed (query completed) 1 branches were processed Finished examining commerce/catalog [Wed Feb 27 12:57:24 MST 2019] Push event to branch BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79 in repository commerce/catalog CREATED event from 10.0.17.214 ⇒ http://ci-m1.body.prod:8080/github-webhook/ with timestamp Wed Feb 27 12:57:16 MST 2019 processed in 2.5 sec [Wed Feb 27 13:02:18 MST 2019] Received Push event to branch BBECOM-18919-Shipping-79 in repository commerce/catalog UPDATED event from 10.0.17.214 ⇒ http://ci-m1.body.prod:8080/github-webhook/ with timestamp Wed Feb 27 13:02:13 MST 2019 13:02:18 Connecting to http://github.body.prod/api/v3 using Jenkins_Github/****** (Github collaborator account for Jenkins) Examining commerce/catalog
two pushes are delivered at the same time and thus two builds are run. The two pushes seem to be 1 from a repo hook and 1 from the org hook.
The repo shows the push
see the webhook to our ci-m1.body.prod server.
at the org level we have another hook
it pushed at 12:57 as well
i'm thinking the two pushes race with each other. the problem is AFAIK it was the github-plugin that setup the two hooks to begin with! so it's causing it's own problems...
wondering if maybe i just have a misconfiguration...but i don't think so.
environment
Jenkins ver. 2.150.1<br/>
github plugin 1.29.0<br/>
github enterprise 2.15
4 attachments
drdamour:
- Original comment link
Raw content of original comment:
also it'd be REALLY nice if that log included the X-GitHub-Delivery request header to help trace issues back to github.
also it'd be REALLY nice if that log included the X-GitHub-Delivery request header to help trace issues back to github.
drdamour:
- Original comment link
Raw content of original comment:
possible workaround is to use throttling from
JENKINS-38552
possible workaround is to use throttling from JENKINS-38552">JENKINS-38552