JAlgoArena icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
JAlgoArena copied to clipboard

Shortest Path in a Graph - specification incomplete

Open pmarecki opened this issue 6 years ago • 1 comments

In the problem "Shortest Path in a Graph" it would be advisible to state explicitly:

a) the weights of the edges are necessarily positive, b) if the graph is directed or not (the class WeightedGraphEdge suggests a directed graph, but it would be good to confirm it; + the "example" does not really present any input data, nor any "arrows" (as for directed graphs), so it remains unspecified), c) we are not given any info on if the graph is supposed to be connected; even if it is, the statement should specify what should be returned if no path exists between "start" and "target" (if the graph is directed),

These have essential influence on the type of algorithm that can be correctly applied to the problem.

pmarecki avatar Sep 23 '18 15:09 pmarecki

a) yes, they are positive b) graph is not directed, it's like map where you have connected two cities, but it's weighted c) it's by design, you get head of graph (WeightedGraph) from where you can find all nodes, which can be connected but not necessarily are

let me know if that helps

spolnik avatar Sep 24 '18 10:09 spolnik