servlet
servlet copied to clipboard
jakartaee
Make web.xml accessible prior to ServletContext initialisation
It would be useful if one could access the contents of the web.xml file, prior to the ServletContext being available.
A use case for this is in writing CDI extensions, where it would be useful to access web.xml configuration data. Currently this is not possible to achieve in a portable way, as the ServletContext has not yet started, and is not available to CDI extensions (in EE environments at least).
Since the WEB-INF folder is not on the classpath, using the context ClassLoader is not possible. Perhaps the solution to this is as simple as adding the WEB-INF folder to the application classpath?
- Issue Imported From: https://github.com/javaee/servlet-spec/issues/9
- Original Issue Raised By:@glassfishrobot
- Original Issue Assigned To: @shingwaichan
@glassfishrobot Commented rojkov said: I think this needs a use case. I can't not suggest that parsing web.xml yet another time should be avoided. Possibly, we can define a pre-start phase that makes the xml available in parsed state.
@glassfishrobot Commented bleathem said: A use case is as I stated in the issue description, where one wants to access the web.xml from a CDI extension. For instance, to determine the JSF project stage, to conditionally activate different beans in production and development.
@glassfishrobot Commented @shingwaichan said: At this time, we don't expose the content of web.xml in Servlet API. Where do you want to access the information contained in the descriptor and how can we reconcile the information specified by annotation? It will be consider in the future release.
@glassfishrobot Commented @shingwaichan said: Adding it to the bucket of FUTURE_RELEASE
@glassfishrobot Commented @edburns said: Would it be sufficient to just make the WEB-INF/web.xml accessible or must all the fragements be considered as well? Also, we need to consider how useful this is in the case where the configuration comes from annotations.
@glassfishrobot Commented gregwilkins said: Also it would be good to have "prior to ServletContext initialisation" defined. Is this during calls to ServletContainerInitializers? In which case much of the content of the web.xml is available via API (and if not then we could add some more API).
I would really rather avoid encouraging other parsing web.xml, as this does not cover configuration from fragments, API, annotation etc.
@glassfishrobot Commented This issue was imported from java.net JIRA SERVLET_SPEC-9
@gregw My suggestion here would be to look at what is missing from the ServletContext API that those CDI extensions are looking for. As CDI is bootstrapped using a ServletContainerInitializer it can access the ServletContext API at that time. Where the actual configuration came from should be irrelevant to the CDI extension as the ServletContext API is the 'materialized view' of a web application where configuration is concerned.
