Andy Fingerhut

> These are so similar to existing tables (the comments even show the equivalence), I think it would be nicer if we could somehow implement this using a table property....

The 2022-Dec-05 P4 language design work group meeting resulted in the `list` type being added to the P4 language spec, and it is part of open source p4c as I...

Here is link to issue proposing generalizing P4 tables in language design work group, which was discussed early in 2023, but not accepted: https://github.com/p4lang/p4-spec/issues/1209

The control plane might not know the entries added by the data plane as they are added, but as long as the control plane supports a "read all entries and...

@kamalakannanr89 Are you interested in creating a PR for the PNA specification document that would start by saying that the combination of add_on_miss=true and direct resources on a table are...

I would recommend a new sub-section of section 7, since it is an extern object we are explaining.

So far there has been little use of MUST/SHALL/SHOULD capitalized like many IETF RFCs have in P4.org specifications. We can discuss whether there should be, but that is the current...

@mariobaldi It would be good to put these in a separate directory for now, until the p4test front end compiles them without errors, to avoid Github CI issues.

@mariobaldi I spent a little time editing your 2 example programs so that `p4test` compiles them with 0 error messages using the latest version of p4c code, and the latest...

@pbhide asked: "Do we expect all types of table action parameters to be writable (e.g. TCAM tables...)?" My personal answer: A target supports what the target developers choose to enable...