pytm icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
pytm copied to clipboard

DE01 Data Flow Sniffing vs DE02 Weak Credential Transit

Open colesmj opened this issue 5 years ago • 4 comments

DE02 is a more specific variant of DE01. Two questions come to mind:

  1. Is it necessary?
  2. Would a threat-relationship descriptor be useful, e.g. threat A follows from threat B (similar to CWE's model of relationships)?

colesmj avatar Oct 21 '18 15:10 colesmj

Also AA02 seems to cover DE02 (duplicate threat?)

colesmj avatar Oct 21 '18 15:10 colesmj

Looks like this issue is not valid anymore, DE02 has been repurpose into a different threat.

nineinchnick avatar Oct 04 '20 11:10 nineinchnick

DE03 is now sniffing, and so DE01 and DE03 now might be duplicates.

colesmj avatar Jun 25 '23 14:06 colesmj

Since DE01 and DE03 are CAPEC-117: interception and CAPEC-157: Sniffing Attacks and 117 is a parent of 157 it is no wonder that both sound similar.

What is strange is the condition of the two are very different

DE01:

https://github.com/izar/pytm/blob/c4a81a451cb4e974098beec4ddc9abef79fd6376/pytm/threatlib/threats.json#L196

DE03:

https://github.com/izar/pytm/blob/c4a81a451cb4e974098beec4ddc9abef79fd6376/pytm/threatlib/threats.json#L527

The question does it makes sense to separate the two, is yes as long as they have different conditions. But I agree that they are very similar and it is not helpful to have two alerts for one problem.

raphaelahrens avatar Mar 14 '24 15:03 raphaelahrens