invidious icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
invidious copied to clipboard

[Bug] The alias of the commentators is sometimes shown instead of their nickname

Open unnamed25 opened this issue 3 years ago • 5 comments

I've been noticed that the alias of the commentators is sometimes shown instead of their nickname. Fixed by reloading the page, after which the nicknames return to their place. Instance where this behavior was observed: https://invidious.baczek.me/ Before the page is reloaded. unnamed After the page is reloaded. unnamed2

unnamed25 avatar Mar 11 '23 14:03 unnamed25

Unfortunately this is caused by YouTube, sometimes they return the names and other times the channel handles, when they return the channel handles the channel names aren't in the response at all, so Invidious can only show the handles in those cases.

absidue avatar Mar 12 '23 11:03 absidue

It seems that it is now completely broken, because aliases are now displayed for all commentators, regardless of the number of page reloads and regardless of the instance.

ghost avatar Jun 26 '23 19:06 ghost

@unnamed25 As mentioned in my comment above this is how it looks on YouTube too, Invidious can't magically make YouTube return information that it doesn't even return for it's own website.

This isn't an Invidious bug, Invidious is just showing you the information it gets from YouTube.

absidue avatar Jun 26 '23 19:06 absidue

@absidue How then does YouTube handle such a case? He can't magically take the normal names of commentators out of nowhere.

ghost avatar Jun 27 '23 08:06 ghost

YouTube displays the channel handles too, you can see the full name if you click through to the channel.

Channel handles are only allowed to contain ASCII characters and have to be unique, channel names can contain any number of Unicode characters and don't have to be unique. I highly suspect that the switch to showing channel handles, is an attempt to reduce the number of scams and porn bots in comment sections, that pretend to be the channel they are commenting on.

absidue avatar Jun 27 '23 08:06 absidue