Identifier containing a space in transparency-obligation-organization

[ioggstream]

Question

@giorgialodi is this correct? https://github.com/italia/daf-ontologie-vocabolari-controllati/blob/f58478950109bcfeb712bd274618fed685e6faaf/VocabolariControllati/classifications-for-transparency/transparency-obligation/transparency-obligation-organization.ttl#L380

The identifier is 040102%20040201 -> the URL contains a space

Issue related to

[ (ioggstream-125) rpolli@rpolli daf-ontologie-vocabolari-controllati]$ frictionless validate VocabolariControllati/classifications-for-transparency/transparency-obligation/transparency-obligation-administration.csv 
# -------
# invalid: VocabolariControllati/classifications-for-transparency/transparency-obligation/transparency-obligation-administration.csv
# -------

====  =====  ==========  ======================================================================================================================
row   field  code        message                                                                                                               
====  =====  ==========  ======================================================================================================================
1379      1  type-error  Type error in the cell "040102 040201" in row "1379" and field "id_obbligo" at position "1": type is "integer/default"
1476      1  type-error  Type error in the cell "040102 040201" in row "1476" and field "id_obbligo" at position "1": type is "integer/default"
1573      1  type-error  Type error in the cell "040102 040201" in row "1573" and field "id_obbligo" at position "1": type is "integer/default"
1670      1  type-error  Type error in the cell "040102 040201" in row "1670" and field "id_obbligo" at position "1": type is "integer/default"
1767      1  type-error  Type error in the cell "040102 040201" in row "1767" and field "id_obbligo" at position "1": type is "integer/default"
1864      1  type-error  Type error in the cell "040102 040201" in row "1864" and field "id_obbligo" at position "1": type is "integer/default"

[giorgialodi]

I think it is like that when it is generated automatically from some fields containing spaces. This RDF file was generated probably automatically from some tables and in one case the code in the table had a space ( I am guessing, I did not create personally this RDF file). When this happens, in the URI the space is replaced with % by some automatic systems. It is not a bug/error. Obviously, if you refer to that URI you have to include %. I do not like that much to be honest, but change a URI is a critical operation. I would leave it as it is.

[ioggstream]

I tracked down 040102 040201 to transparency obligation... it seems that there only exists the 040102 identifier.

Can we check/ask whether the correct value is 040102?

[ioggstream]

iiuc URLs cannot contain %20 in the path segment.

[ioggstream]

@giorgialodi URLs cannot include %20 nor blank in a path segment. The blank/%20 terminates the URI and the following part is ignored. This must be fixed

[giorgialodi]

Sorry @ioggstream but when there is a space and the URI is automatically generated the space is encoded with %20 because space is not admitted in URIs. So there is an encoding of the space that is added. As I said above, this is possible. I do not like very much but you are changing a persistent URIs, which is a critical operation to avoid as much as possible. The problem that I think is the most relevant one is that the identifier contains two values instead one only. I have to check this before proceeding with this critical modification.

[ioggstream]

@giorgialodi ok, so pls check if that's the correct URI since I am quite sure that this value is a typo :)

[giorgialodi]

@bfabio @mfortini @Clou-dia la questione dell'URI sballato è stata risolta quando sono state apportate le modifiche al vocabolario. Io chiuderei l'issue.