internetstandards
Feedback solved in new designs Internet.nl
Goodmorning everybody,
Hereby the new designs of the website. We discussed somethings in the meeting last Thursday, what I didn't resolved yet. I look forward to the feedback so we can wrap it up and make the designs final!
Desktop:
Mobile:
These designs are part of Website Redesign issue https://github.com/internetstandards/Internet.nl/issues/1252
Feedback on previous version: https://github.com/internetstandards/Internet.nl/issues/1460#issuecomment-2230424868
Joint feedback (under construction)
General
Desktop
Mobile
While it's great to use github for openness, I'm starting to see github issues are an awful platform for these kind of reviews. This is 80 pages of content, there is no way we will review this accurately, also because all coherence between pages is lost. If we want more design iterations, we should find a more appropriate platform, even if it is not open.
That said, I think this is looking good, and have only one comment: I don't think we should have modal overlay that appears while the test is running (the window with spinners with a dimmed out website on the background). It looks good, and seems sensible, but will lead to one of two situations:
- We allow users to click away the modal, returning to the website, abandoning their running test. This is undesirable, because tests can take a while to run, and we want to capture the user as well as possible. So it shouldn't be too alluring for them to give up waiting.
- We do not allow closing the modal like this, but that breaks user experience expectations.
The waiting-for-test-results experience should therefore be on a separate page.
Also, just keeping a note: we really wanted to improve the spacing for the tech table, in width, but we haven't improved on that at all. It's much too cramped now.
