web-monetization-extension
web-monetization-extension copied to clipboard
interledger
[BUG] Misleading successful payment msg even when wallet payment fails
Steps to reproduce
Tester feedback
Used rafiki.money to setup 2 different wallets, to easily track my WM sending wallet (starting balance of $50) and receiving wallet (starting balance of $0).
Both wallets are in USD, they're configured to have WM-enabled payment pointers.
- connect WM extension to the sending wallet.
- setup the WM playground to receive payments into 2 payment pointers on the receiving wallet
- use the WM extension to make continuous payments to the WM playground
- use the WM extension to make a one-time payment of $2.50, which split the amount in half, to send to each of the 2 receiving pay-pointers
Observation: The extension shows a "Payment successful" message Results: Waited 5 minutes...30 minutes...about 20 hrs but there were no successful, or even rejected transactions, and the balances remained unchanged, for each wallet.
Expected result
None of the payments from the WM extension actually succeeded, and so the extension should not show a message indicating successful payment.
Actual result
When making a one-time payment, the extension showed a "Payment successful" message even though the transaction didn't actually succeed.
Screenshots or videos
No response
Additional context
I was concerned that maybe the WM playground or extension may be doing something unexpected. When I repeat the scenario using a Fynbos wallet, the payments go through. Erica didn't use the WM playground, instead she added the receiving payment pointers onto a website, but unfortunately she made similar observations.
Operating system
Windows
Operating system version
10
Browsers
Chrome
Browser version
Version 128.0.6613.115 (Official Build) (64-bit)
Extension version
private beta release
@tselit Can you share the wallet address of:
- connected wallet
- and the website?
Sure @sidvishnoi . The website was the WM playground, and the connected wallet was:
$ilp.rafiki.money/3rd-new-wm
(this was created specifically for WM, with the "I want to use this payment pointer for Web Monetization" checkbox ticked)
So me and Radu couldn't both reproduce with non-WM payment pointers. Also note, WM payment pointers are going away soon. The regular ones will work for WM.
Related: https://github.com/interledger/web-monetization-extension/issues/445