historical-world-atlas icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
historical-world-atlas copied to clipboard

Missing .prj files?

Open Mike-Honey opened this issue 6 years ago • 3 comments

These files look very helpful for a project I'm working on, but when I try to upload them to MapBox, it complains that they lack a .prj file (projection).

The results do appear to be incorrectly projected e.g. some country boundaries are shown into the ocean, others inland from the shore.

I'm a geospatial newbie, so any help or hints appreciated. I'm specifically working on the 1914.zip file.

Mike-Honey avatar Jun 23 '18 06:06 Mike-Honey

I think the shapes there should be unprojected. Not sure why they are not properly projected by Mapbox. But you could try to load the shapes in QGIS and reproject them to any projection, then maybe also export with a .prj file

ilyabo avatar Jun 23 '18 13:06 ilyabo

Thanks @ilyabo for your prompt reply. So which projection should I use?

Mike-Honey avatar Jun 24 '18 13:06 Mike-Honey

This is a late answer, but it depends what you're showing and why. (I'm speaking in general terms; I don't actually know what MapBox supports.)

If you just want to display the continental US, you probably want to use the Albers Equal-Area conic projection, which is what most modern US governmental departments use. Canada only? Lambert conformal conic projection. (Other northern and southern countries will similarly benefit from conic projections.)

This is a great guide from CUNY that we've used at my workplace: http://www.geo.hunter.cuny.edu/~jochen/gtech201/lectures/lec6concepts/map%20coordinate%20systems/how%20to%20choose%20a%20projection.htm

If you're visualizing dots on the full globe, note what it says under "Why equal-area projections are essential for dot-density maps?"

catherineomega avatar Sep 26 '18 16:09 catherineomega