slack icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
slack copied to clipboard

Send Draft Pull Request Comments to Slack

Open circuitfive opened this issue 3 years ago • 10 comments

By the way, I'd like to send Draft PR comments to Slack. Is that possible...? If I can't, I wouldn't want to use Draft PR.

Also wondering if it is possible to send Draft PR comments to Slack...

Originally posted by @markmesscu in https://github.com/integrations/slack/issues/795#issuecomment-966572214

When somebody makes a comment on a Draft PR, we'd like and option to see it in Slack the same way as a comment on an ordinary PR.

circuitfive avatar Nov 11 '21 20:11 circuitfive

This used to be present in the original slack integration and when we upgraded, it went away.

We miss it so much -- I get that it can get noisy for larger teams -- but for us it's a signal to jump in and start collaborating on a PR and that work is progressing.

Please add it back as an option so we can turn it on 🙏

sjmueller avatar Jan 25 '22 03:01 sjmueller

I think this is helpful for now. https://github.com/marketplace/wip/

Convert PR to no draft and start the title with 🚧.

k-utsumi avatar Jan 25 '22 13:01 k-utsumi

Surprised by this! Seems obvious that all comments should show up? I could see that some teams want the granular control, but for us it's just a missing piece.

JasonTheAdams avatar Feb 04 '22 01:02 JasonTheAdams

any update or eta when draft PRs or their comments will be available again?

sjmueller avatar Mar 02 '22 16:03 sjmueller

I hope it.

t2y avatar Mar 14 '22 00:03 t2y

Because of the lack of this feature, draft pull requests are not available for our project.

Please implement this feature.

yuki2006 avatar Apr 27 '22 15:04 yuki2006

we've also been forced to avoid using draft PRs -- please bring back the ability to subscribe

sjmueller avatar Apr 27 '22 15:04 sjmueller

Any news on this? Slack is for collaboration but now we can't collaborate on Draft PRs

elgehelge avatar Apr 12 '23 06:04 elgehelge

What a weird limitation. Please add it back.

archon810 avatar Feb 08 '24 18:02 archon810

our workaround is to create the PR as a regular one, then immediately convert to Draft PR -- the initial slack notification goes out and gives signal to the team on slack

note that subsequent comments on the draft won't show in slack until it's converted back to regular PR

sjmueller avatar Feb 08 '24 21:02 sjmueller