inspire-next
inspire-next copied to clipboard
inspirehep
Holdingpen: Update Conflicts: aligning authors
Especially for authors of collaborations one needs to see the updated field next to the old one to be able to decide.
Expected Behavior
The unmatched fields of existing record and update should be ordered and displayed next to each other.
Current Behavior
The unmatched fields are appended at the very end.
Steps to Reproduce (for bugs)
Most update conflicts are from big collaborations like 1172909, 1172841, 1172733, 1172597
Similar problem if one author was not matched: short name, UTF-8 (Umlaut) I would like to know what is the existing information. Chances are someone checked that before. Need an easy way to say: keep the old information for authors.
Examples: 1154970, 1154732
Different author lists on preprint and published version. arXiv should not (attempt) to overwrite published information. Need an easy way to say: keep the old information for authors.
example: 1154694
bad author name in INSPIRE Update of name is good but need to keep affiliation. I copied the affiliation into the new author + reject. Is there a better way to do this?
Example: 1154840
Legacy behavior
If one author is replaced (Glover, Nigel -> Author, A.New) it's an in-line replacement. I.e. The authors stay aligned. The curator can choose to replace, add or ignore the new author.
If the number of authors is different, the alignment doesn't work. I guess it aligns by position, not by name.
