indi-3rdparty icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
indi-3rdparty copied to clipboard

celestron-aux Missed move command in one axis

Open luzik opened this issue 3 years ago • 2 comments

While testing caux using inbuilt math plugin, align was bad as usual (10 sec max exposure time), and then I parked in sweet spot of alt ~0, az ~0 and cleared old sync points. My first point solver error was only ~200arcsec (this mean that park position was almost perfect), second and third great too. With this math set up I was able to take 60seconds pictures with stars as dots! This also confirm how correct park position 0,0 affect alignment with 'inbuilt math' plugin.

The BUG: I wanted add one more align point, set goto (it was a vector from actual location 10deg up, ~30 deg left) and my mount did not move in AZ at all, but KStars showed this move on map and plate solve give me over 90000arcsec error. I parked and park position physically also changed by about 30deg AZ.

Something similar did happened me few days earlier, but I wasn't sure what really happened.

I know that this is not reproducible, I do understand that there is not enough data to track a bug, but please help me set up debug for such behavior and I will provide as much info I can.

Can it be some kind of hardware issue ?

Can it be even possible this happened ? I always thought that scope position in Kstars is taken as feedback from mount physical encoders that just can't be wrong.

luzik avatar Feb 13 '22 09:02 luzik

For this driver specifically, there are multiple translations steps since it goes via the mount model. Enable logging to see what actually happens at the lowest level, this is only way to possible track bugs of this kind. I couldn't use the in-built mount model for this, and had to develop the Nearest plugin which turns out to be more reliable in real-life scenarios.

Are you using this for Alt-Az mount? or Equatorial? I never tested on the latter and there are possibly quite a few bugs with equatorial handling.

knro avatar Mar 22 '22 05:03 knro

Evolution mount in Alt-Az mode. I will try today with debug. Any hints how to setup debug logging ? Last I tried it wasn't so obvious.

luzik avatar Mar 22 '22 08:03 luzik

Error reporting instructions here: https://indilib.org/individuals/logs-howto.html

A better method is to use Ekos Debugger

sudo apt-get -y install ekosdebugger

knro avatar Nov 16 '22 05:11 knro

@luzik Any further updates on this? INDI v1.9.9 is due next week so we have time to fix if we could identify the root cause.

knro avatar Nov 20 '22 06:11 knro