Turning Virtual Devices on/off does not work.

[ryanlm]

I am trying to get a Insteon Keypad's buttons to work. In short, I created virtual on/off devices and used triggers in Indigo to set the state. However, when mapping the virtual on/off device to a HomeBridge switch, it only works one way via the Home app on iOS. It does update correctly when using the physical switch/keypad.

Expected Behavior

Clicking the virtual device presented as a switch, tapping it should turn it on, and tapping it again should turn it off.

Current Behavior

The state never changes in Indigo of the virtual device. The logs show either the ON request coming in or the OFF request coming in, but not each. Stated another way, if I create one virtual device it will only see ON requests from the Home App. If I create another one it may only see OFF requests. Seems random.

Steps to Reproduce (for bugs)

1. Create a virtual on/off device.
2. Map it via HomeKit Bridge in Indigo as a switch.
3. Tap its button in the Home App, the state should not change in Indigo.

Versions

v1.0.2 released on July 18, 2018 Fresh install of this plugin and

Configuration

   HomeKit Bridge                  {
        "platforms": [
                {
                        "protocol": "http", 
                        "name": "HomeKit Bridge Server", 
                        "listenPort": "8445", 
                        "platform": "Indigo2", 
                        "host": "127.0.0.1", 
                        "debug": false, 
                        "serverId": 637357676, 
                        "port": "8558"
                }
        ], 
        "bridge": {
                "username": "CC:22:3D:E3:CE:10", 
                "name": "Indigo HomeKit Bridge", 
                "pin": "031-45-154", 
                "port": "51826"
        }, 
        "accessories": [], 
        "description": "HomeKit configuration generated by HomeKit Bridge on 2018-09-22 13:59:00.934000 for device Indigo HomeKit Bridge"
}

Homebridge Log / Command Output

[2018-9-22 13:59:02] Homebridge is running on port 51826.
[2018-9-22 13:59:04] [HomeKit Bridge Server] Test Switch: get(On) => false
[2018-9-22 13:59:10] [HomeKit Bridge Server] Test Switch: set(On) false -> true
[2018-9-22 13:59:10] [HomeKit Bridge Server] HomeKit Bridge request: http://127.0.0.1:8558/HomeKit?objId=280738476&serverId=637357676&jkey=06d7af5627e0f5eb0fe22d6af633dd1e80c390c3439bd35ffb600b90bc8bc11c&cmd=setCharacteristic&On=true
[2018-9-22 13:59:10] [HomeKit Bridge Server] Test Switch: updateCharacteristicValue(On): true -> false
[2018-9-22 13:59:18] [HomeKit Bridge Server] Test Switch: set(On) false -> true
[2018-9-22 13:59:18] [HomeKit Bridge Server] HomeKit Bridge request: http://127.0.0.1:8558/HomeKit?objId=280738476&serverId=637357676&jkey=06d7af5627e0f5eb0fe22d6af633dd1e80c390c3439bd35ffb600b90bc8bc11c&cmd=setCharacteristic&On=true
[2018-9-22 13:59:18] [HomeKit Bridge Server] Test Switch: updateCharacteristicValue(On): true -> false
[2018-9-22 13:59:23] [HomeKit Bridge Server] Test Switch: set(On) false -> true
[2018-9-22 13:59:23] [HomeKit Bridge Server] HomeKit Bridge request: http://127.0.0.1:8558/HomeKit?objId=280738476&serverId=637357676&jkey=06d7af5627e0f5eb0fe22d6af633dd1e80c390c3439bd35ffb600b90bc8bc11c&cmd=setCharacteristic&On=true
[2018-9-22 13:59:23] [HomeKit Bridge Server] Test Switch: updateCharacteristicValue(On): true -> false
[2018-9-22 13:59:31] [HomeKit Bridge Server] Test Switch: set(On) false -> true
[2018-9-22 13:59:31] [HomeKit Bridge Server] HomeKit Bridge request: http://127.0.0.1:8558/HomeKit?objId=280738476&serverId=637357676&jkey=06d7af5627e0f5eb0fe22d6af633dd1e80c390c3439bd35ffb600b90bc8bc11c&cmd=setCharacteristic&On=true
[2018-9-22 13:59:31] [HomeKit Bridge Server] Test Switch: updateCharacteristicValue(On): true -> false
[2018-9-22 13:59:33] [HomeKit Bridge Server] Virtual Keypad Button: get(On) => true
[2018-9-22 13:59:36] [HomeKit Bridge Server] Virtual Keypad Button: set(On) true -> false
[2018-9-22 13:59:36] [HomeKit Bridge Server] HomeKit Bridge request: http://127.0.0.1:8558/HomeKit?objId=1736185922&serverId=637357676&jkey=b26972baa0f89b62c31e6e12a10669486e26ce322971462094e343f3b9fde8b5&cmd=setCharacteristic&On=false
[2018-9-22 13:59:36] [HomeKit Bridge Server] Virtual Keypad Button: updateCharacteristicValue(On): false -> true
[2018-9-22 14:09:43] [HomeKit Bridge Server] Garage Entryway Keypad: get(On) => true
[2018-9-22 14:09:43] [HomeKit Bridge Server] Test Switch: get(On) => false
[2018-9-22 14:09:43] [HomeKit Bridge Server] Virtual Keypad Button: get(On) => true

Device Simulation Report

	
	Service : 
		alias : Test Switch
		model : 
		subModel : 
		indigoType : indigo.RelayDevice
		pluginType : indigo.RelayDevice.com.perceptiveautomation.indigoplugin.devicecollection.pseudoRelay
		type : Switch
		desc : Switch
		objId : 280738476
		serverId : 637357676
		invertOnState : False
		convertFahrenheit : False
		required : (List)
			On : False
		optional : (List)
		native : True
		requiresPlugin : (List)
		actions : (List)
			Action : (HomeKitAction)
				Characteristic : On
				When : equal
				Value : False (bool)
				Value2 : 0 (bool)
				Command : device.turnOff
				Arguments : [280738476]
				monitors : {280738476: 'attr_onState'}
			Action : (HomeKitAction)
				Characteristic : On
				When : equal
				Value : True (bool)
				Value2 : 0 (bool)
				Command : device.turnOn
				Arguments : [280738476]
				monitors : {280738476: 'attr_onState'}
		loadOptional : False
		characterDict : (Dict)
			On : False
	```

[Colorado4Wheeler]

Hmmm, I have a dozen virtual on/off devices working in HomeKit via HKB and your device simulation shows that it is correctly detecting the state. The logs also look correct. Can you verify that using the Indigo UI will properly turn on and off the device AND (the AND is critical here) that you can see the device state change in Indigo AND (yup, again) that the variable you assigned to the virtual group as the device state is changing each time?