EDI.Net icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
EDI.Net copied to clipboard

[discussion] Comparing with ediFabric

Open hellboy81 opened this issue 7 years ago • 4 comments

I am looking fo some comparisons/benchmarks comparing this library with EdiFabric

hellboy81 avatar Jun 22 '17 07:06 hellboy81

I have not taken the time to do such a benchmark. I guess it depends on the scenario. I would like to put something together with BenchmarkDotNet but no actual plan. I am open to contribution though.

cleftheris avatar Jun 22 '17 07:06 cleftheris

I mean I am new with EDIFACT format and I don't know which library can be/should be used for exporting only cases

hellboy81 avatar Jun 22 '17 07:06 hellboy81

It depends on your scenario. Both libraries are capable of producing EDIFACT.

cleftheris avatar Jun 22 '17 10:06 cleftheris

I have used both for sample files. I would say that both libraries are just about as fast as one another. One big difference is EDI.Net is open source (MIT) where EdiFabric is mostly proprietary (Examples are AGPL). The full version of EdiFabric comes with sample classes like: EF_HIPAA_005010X222A1_837 I also like how EDI.Net has pretty good test coverage. Both are excellent libraries to build out EDI files.

michaelachrisco avatar Jan 29 '18 20:01 michaelachrisco