loader icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
loader copied to clipboard

Is this spec living?

Open foolip opened this issue 8 years ago • 6 comments

I noticed when playing with https://foolip.github.io/day-to-day/ that Loader hasn't had any activity in the last 8 weeks, and in fact there is no directory in web-platform-tests. I'm wondering if I should exclude it or not.

I don't know this space very well, but is this something that would be implemented in JS engines, or on top of them? Is there any implementer interest?

Whatever the state of the document is, making its status clear (in the spec itself) would be great.

foolip avatar Oct 03 '17 16:10 foolip

I'm wondering if I should exclude it or not.

exclude it.

Whatever the state of the document is, making its status clear (in the spec itself) would be great.

https://github.com/whatwg/loader#status

caridy avatar Oct 05 '17 19:10 caridy

Thanks, I'll exclude it! I was hoping that the spec itself (https://whatwg.github.io/loader/) would say something about its status, as certainly I would never go looking at the GitHub repo looking for such information.

foolip avatar Oct 08 '17 07:10 foolip

I was recently pointed to https://github.com/whatwg/html/issues/3161 , which is an attempt to define mappings to allow bare specifiers. That in particular is the use case I'm hoping to see advanced, so I can make use of some of the half-a-million modules in the browser.

That thread also linked to another older general discussion thread on request hooks, https://github.com/whatwg/html/issues/2640

rektide avatar Feb 03 '18 02:02 rektide

I've been told that it's completely abandoned. The repository's dates would reflect this.

stevenvachon avatar Apr 18 '19 19:04 stevenvachon

Last I heard, @caridy is concentrating on Realms as that's needed before they can proceed with this: https://github.com/tc39/proposal-realms

matthewp avatar Apr 18 '19 19:04 matthewp

part of this is now solved by import() and imports map. the other part will be feed into the realms proposal.

caridy avatar Apr 18 '19 20:04 caridy